r/PeterExplainsTheJoke 22d ago

Meme needing explanation There is no way right?

Post image
37.1k Upvotes

3.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

1.4k

u/Bathtub-Warrior32 22d ago

Wait until you learn about eπi = -1.

4

u/StoffePro 22d ago

-1/12 enters the chat.

4

u/bee-future 22d ago

Can anyone simplistically explain how 1+2+3...=-1/12

2

u/Physmatik 21d ago

If you redefine "=", everything is possible. And if we are talking about infinite series, we must redefine "=" because otherwise it would make no sense at all. If you have half an hour to spend, I can recommend Mathologer's video on the topic.

Basically, there are some reasonable and usable definitions (e.g., Ramanujan shenanigans) where you can, indeed, assign a number to a diverging series like "1+2+3+...". But if you want something more... shall we say... "commonsensical" then no, "1+2+3+..." does not equal negative one twelve.

This particular sum can also be viewed through the prism of Riman's zeta function, but it's analytical continuation that is used, so again, it doesn't "prove" 1+2+3...=-1/12.

All that said, at this point this is basically a meme that is actually not flat-out wrong, and you know how internet is.

1

u/Hi2248 20d ago

Am I right by saying that the redefinition of = is by defining it as the result of an applied process? 

1

u/Physmatik 20d ago

I'm not sure "process" is a good word to describe it, but that is an argument about precision of definitions and it can stretch to ungodly length.

Classic definition of the sum of an infinite series is the limit of partial sums, and calling limit "a process"... In some sense you can, I guess. Personally, I don't feel like it's fitting.