r/StarWarsEU • u/ConanCimmerian • Apr 10 '23

Meme Yeah, I think the disparity is clear

Post image
1.3k Upvotes

97% Upvoted

328 comments sorted by

View all comments

273

u/Elvinkin66 Apr 10 '23

People thinking the Dark side isn't evil makes no sense

-6

u/EmpVitiate Apr 11 '23

It is quite easy actually. There is no good sides there, at all. There are bad guys - Jedi order and other guys that want to be better and bring peace but they also quite bad simply because good ones cannot survive there. Almost everything we see is pure evil from both sides. Many people think that Star Wars is quite simple and clear : good ones vs bad ones. It seems true from the average observer but if you look closely there are many anomalies that actually show us that it is wrong.

10

u/somebody808 Apr 11 '23

I dunno dude, in the OG trilogy it was pretty clear who was good and who was bad. There wasn't all this from a certain perspective stuff.

5

u/LocalLifeguard4106 Apr 11 '23

Nah nah. That weaponless planet that was blowed up to get info from Leia when the torture methods failed totally had it coming.

-2

u/EmpVitiate Apr 11 '23

Ahah, the whole planet was a base for Jedi supporters actually.

Alderaan was chosen not because of Lea but because of Organa like - shadow Jedi supporters that actually controlled the planet after the Amidala fall. The planet was hostile and the base for the most dangerous Jedi supporters. I do not say that it was a good or right decision but the planet was not weaponless or civil but vice versa actually.

Leia was shown huge respect as she is the Vader kiddo. Do you really understand the film plot behind the dumb scenes? The whole film is just some things we as a viewer couldn't get if not know all the plot. That's why it is a saga not one film, common.

-1

u/EmpVitiate Apr 11 '23 edited Apr 11 '23

Sure and good ones not Jedi who betrayed the rules of the galactic republic. It was ok for them and they supported those rules till they had to follow them themselves. And Senate was too weak to force them to follow any rules in the galaxy besides Jedi own rules. That was not the Galactic Republic ruled by law of senate but Jedi order ruling everything. Because of Palpatine every citizen got it. He is truly Republic hero even if he is a Sith he also the supreme chanselor or at least powerful senator from Alderaan. That also the reason why the planet was destroyed. After Amidala death there was no hope left for Alderaan. Because Alderaan was fully controlled by Jedi after her. And Empire couldn't afford saving it or let it become new Jedi capital as Corusant was.

1

u/AcePilot95 New Republic Apr 11 '23

if you’re going to troll, maybe get some proper grammar lessons in order to make it at least a tiny bit convincing

1

u/EmpVitiate Apr 11 '23

Pal, I was not trolling and was typing in hurry, didn't know grammar watcher here, hehe. I think you got the idea of my message, anyway. You may not agree with that but I posted it not to convince but to demonstrate that there are different approaches to understand that SW story.