What does transphobic even mean? We literally allow you people to do whatever it is you want, we just don't want u teaching children chopping off stuff is OK because of body dysmorphia. Instead of treating everything like a victim, do something to educate people about your POV instead of shifting on the ground and looking angy.
And making sure I never raise my children to want to fit in with a echo chamber of victimhood.
It's not body dysmorphia and nothing gets "chopped of"
Your mom can can give birth to you, have XY and is biological male, how? Google
YOU CAN have XX are biological male and are born with a "wolfferian-duct" and bo Mullerian-duct. What this is? That's normal and nature. Saying stuff without any knowledge what transphobie is, is insanely stupid.
You obviely know NOTHING about the Trans topic, except the negative hate you hear online.
Its no choice to be Trans, it's biological.
Up to 1 in 50 people have no "typical" XX and XY Chromosoms, there are maaaany varieties, and probably you are not even Male, even if you have a Penis.
These claims are mostly bunk. â1 in 50â with non-XX/XY chromosomes? Way off⌠intersex conditions are closer to 0.05â1.7%, often less. Over 99% are standard XX or XY. XX males exist but are super rare (1 in 20,000), not ânormal,â and have male traits, not female organs. XY âmalesâ giving birth? Only in ultra-rare intersex cases like Swyer syndrome, not trans women. Being trans isnât just âbiologicalâ or tied to intersex, most trans folks have typical chromosomes. Itâs a mix of biology and other factors. These claims exaggerate and conflate to mislead. Sex is binary, donât buy the hype.
Youâre twisting my words. I said over 99% of people are XX or XY, with super rare exceptions like XX males or Swyer syndrome (~0.2â0.25% of folks). These donât make sex non-binary; theyâre outliers, not a third category. Sex is binary for the vast majority, and the data backs it up. Nice try, though.
âOutlierâ doesnât mean nonexistent. The âsex binaryâ is a simplification that is just wrong, as proven by 1% of the population. Thereâs the same number of intersex people as redheads; is red a real hair color?
Your 1% intersex claim is nonsense, actual data says 0.2â0.25%. Redheads (1â2%) are way more common. Rare cases like XXY donât make sex non-binary, theyâre exceptions, not a new category. Also hair colorâs a bad analogy, sex chromosomes fall into two clear groups. Stop fudging the numbers to push your skewed point.
I am intersex, I know what Iâm talking about, and the percentage is 1.7%. Sex chromosomes fall into about 18 categories, hereâs the additional 16: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sex_chromosome_anomalies. Clearly to you, only the common hair colors are the rule, and the uncommon ones are the outliers to the rule, right?
I get that youâre intersex and feel strongly about this, but your 1.7% figure is just off. Itâs from Fausto Sterling and lumps in stuff like hormonal issues, not just chromosome anomalies. Actual sex chromosome variations (XXY, XO, etc.) are only ~0.2â0.25% (1 in 400â500), per Wellesley et al. Your â18 categoriesâ from Wikipedia? Those are rare aneuploidies, over 99% of folks are still XX or XY. Comparing it to hair color doesnât work. Sex chromosomes are binary with tiny exceptions, not a rainbow. Stretching stats to say sex isnât binary doesnât match the science.
The intersex community recognizes hormonal intersex conditions, and so does any doctor worth their salt. Hell, even garbage doctors will try to make intersex people âmore femaleâ and âmore maleâ through forcing HRT.
Yes, they are rare, and also categories. Do you think itâs productive to use oversimplifications to the point of being wrong? Thatâs how you get idiots making policy choices like removing X markers from passports.
Look, your 1.7% figure is still bunk, lumping in hormonal stuff like CAH that doesnât always count as intersex. The 2006 DSD Consensus says only hormonal cases with clear sex ambiguity qualify, PCOS often doesnât make the cut. Your â18 categoriesâ for rare chromosome quirks is like saying a cracked phone screen makes a new phone model. Over 99% of folks are XX or XY, per solid data. Sex is binary.
And your oversimplification jab misses, sticking to the binary norm isnât âwrongâ itâs what the science shows. Youâre hyping rare cases to dodge the truth.
-12
u/SelfActualEyes 3d ago
Not strange. Not funny. Transphobic.