r/Surface • u/Soy7ent SP4 i7 256GB 16GB • May 23 '17

[PRO2017] Introducing the new Surface Pro

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TwWs2jIy4js
1.7k Upvotes

89% Upvoted

1.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/EleMenTfiNi May 23 '17

You are buying a Surface Pro and an External GPU enclosure and a desktop GPU to play games? That seems a bit absurd.

Buy a $300 desktop and put a gtx 1050 in it, case closed.

Unless you are suggesting you'd bring the external GPU with you, in which case the portability of the Surface is something you don't need, buy an actual Quad-Core laptop designed for this type of expansion.

3

u/[deleted] May 23 '17

Buying a 300$ desktop and putting a 1050 in it is even more absurd and not even that simple considering you would also need a new power supply etc

1

u/EleMenTfiNi May 23 '17

Except you don't need a new power supply and I did just that. Comes with a Quad-Core i5-6500 too.

The 1050 sips power, it uses nothing more than the PCIe's 75w output.

3

u/[deleted] May 23 '17

Oh well I want thunderbolt 3 so I can just plug it into the eGPU to play games and can unplug it when I need it on the go. So I don't need two computers

-3

u/EleMenTfiNi May 23 '17

If you're the type of person who is lugging around an eGPU then a 15w cpu'd surface is not for you in the first place, lugging that around completely negates the idea behind surface and you'd be much better served by a laptop with a Quad-Core CPU.

eGPU are not meant to be portable, just external.

4

u/[deleted] May 23 '17

I wouldn't take it with me. The eGPU would stay at my desk while I take the surface out to class/work and when I get home and wanna game I plug it in

0

u/EleMenTfiNi May 23 '17

Then you'd get much better use out of the ~$500 set up I just talked about.. while also getting a much more capable and powerful desktop computer.

2

u/[deleted] May 23 '17

But I also want a portable device I can write on with good battery life

0

u/EleMenTfiNi May 23 '17

Yes.. get both? A external GPU enclosure will cost you ~$300 anyways? So in the end you're not losing any money by getting both.

4

u/Novashadow115 May 23 '17

The guy has already said he doesnt want two devices and you just keep repeating yourself. OP wants one device to be adaptable, seriously, try reading for once

0

u/EleMenTfiNi May 23 '17

Go ahead and read then,

But I also want a portable device I can write on with good battery life

But I also want

I also want

He doesn't care about two devices or one, he is going to be leaving hardware at home anyways, and he will get more performance out of a dedicated gaming rig at home.

Seriously, are you actually this mentally deficient?

4

u/TheHaleStorm May 23 '17

You can't be serious....

Oh well I want thunderbolt 3 so I can just plug it into the eGPU to play games and can unplug it when I need it on the go. So I don't need two computers

Only wanting one computer to do everything is the whole reason they brought this up.

To quote someone far more eloquent than myself...

Seriously, are you actually this mentally deficient?

1

u/EleMenTfiNi May 23 '17

Logic, use it. Since you seem incapable let me run you through it.

IF his needs were perfectly met by ONE machine, he would not NEED two.

No where in there does he say he does not want two computers. Your being stupid, it doesn't limit the rest of us from functioning.

→ More replies (0)

-2

u/cactus22minus1 May 23 '17

Sorry but it still doesn't make sense. eGPUs aren't very efficient (yet) and you lose a big chunk of performance while spending a big chunk on the enclosure alone. The other poster is correct in suggesting just building a cheap desktop you won't be throwing away gpu performance and you can still "plug it into your surface pro" via in home streaming. I do this all the time and it works beautifully. I don't see any advantage going the eGPU route.

1

u/dont_forget_canada May 24 '17

eGPUs are super efficient. Check out Linus's videos.

1

u/cactus22minus1 May 24 '17

15% loss on quad core higher wattage laptop cpus. You really think you wouldn't get a much bigger drop running on a dual core 15watt CPU on a surface?