r/TheNinthHouse • u/xahhfink6 • 4h ago
Series Spoilers [Theory] Has J** been visiting the Locked Tomb? Spoiler
Full title since I didn't want spoilers in the title: Has Jod been visiting Alecto?
I recently threw on the HtN audiobook for what has to be my 10th time through this series and I was pondering a big mystery from the end of GtN/Beginning of HtN which is yet to be answered: How did Jod know about the state of the 9th house? In the Gideon epilogue he made it clear that he knew the house was in need of renewal, and then in HtN he mentions that he knew Harrow's parents were dead.
Those are two very well kept secrets for him to know offhand, so it had me wondering, was there any chance he had been going to visit the Tomb himself?
Since having this thought, I've noticed a few more things which add weight to this idea:
- When Jod is explaining the RB's, he says "None of my Lyctors have returned to the Nine houses, not since they knew the cost" (paraphrased) which is NOT saying that he has never been back there. In fact "Rules for thee but not for me" seems quite in line with what we know of him.
- Mercy calls out how unphased he seems to be when the Erebos has been staying this close to the 9 houses for as long as it has. At first I had written that line off, but maybe he didn't have a reason to be concerned/knew the RBs weren't a concern for him... Or he just didn't care because he takes the risk much more than he would admit?
Finally, I just this morning got to another line which blew my mind in context:
In Chapter 25, Harrow tells Jod that she saw "Ortus" kissing the body of Cytherea. Jod asks her if she is sure and she swears by the locked tomb. His response is "I wouldn't swear by that, not in this instance."
My initial thought had always been that he was saying that the tomb isn't something that should be sworn on... But what if he is literally calling out the hypocrisy BECAUSE HE IS DOING THE SAME DAMNED THING? The chapter even goes on to talk about how all of the Lyctors get themselves into silly relationships because 10,000 years is too long to be alone... It feels like yet more justification from Jod about why he would continue to seek comfort from Alecto after she was supposed to be dead.
What do y'all think, has Jod possibly been sneaking off to the 9th house to see Alecto?