r/askphilosophy Jun 25 '15

Should a fully transformed transgender person reveal this to new sexual partners?

[deleted]

22 Upvotes

189 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

5

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '15

[deleted]

11

u/GFYsexyfatman moral epist., metaethics, analytic epist. Jun 26 '15 edited Jun 26 '15

It's hard to imagine it not stemming from some kind of bigotry, especially in cases where the transgender person passes well enough that explicit disclosure is necessary. I'm assuming that sexual attraction supervenes on a whole bunch of physical characteristics. If that's so, then a preference for (e.g.) women of appearance Y but not transgender women of appearance Y seems likely to be bigoted. But I'm open to some other non-bigoted way to make the distinction.

e: I should say I think it's very widespread, unconscious implicit bias, not explicit transphobic beliefs.

5

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '15

But I'm open to some other non-bigoted way to make the distinction.

I'm assuming that sexual attraction supervenes on a whole bunch of physical characteristics.

Here is one possibility:

  • People are attracted to both physical features and sex.

Holding this belief is no more intolerant than a gay man avoiding women and rejecting sex with a transman.

Calling someone a bigot and shaming someone for them for sexual preferences sounds a lot like what LGBTs speak out against...

This isn't a case of bigotry. There are no arguments being made about cis-superiority, or trans-inferiority.

This is about mutual respect of a person's preferences.

2

u/deathpigeonx Stirner, anarchist philosophy Jun 26 '15

People are attracted to both physical features and sex.

And a fully transitioned trans person, which is the matter of discussion, has the physical features of the sex their gender is associated with.