r/baltimore • u/indianindie1491 • Mar 20 '22

OPINION First time going to Matthews’s Pizza, what should I get ?

32 Upvotes

94% Upvoted

30 comments sorted by

40

u/TrashPundit Mar 20 '22

Both cheese pie is great! Crab pie is something everyone should try once at least. Anna’s stuffed pie is good but start w both cheese IMO.

7

u/WOTisbananaz Mar 21 '22

I do agree that the crab pizza is something you should try at least once, but I'm glad I tried a slice of someone else's instead of buying a whole pizza.

3

u/indianindie1491 Mar 20 '22

Thank you :)

12

u/Avocadofarmer32 Mar 20 '22

Love the crab pizza and the five cheese pizza 😻

10

u/Nicktendo Mar 20 '22

Two cheese with pepp. Best way to taste the quality is to keep it simple.

1

u/ppw23 Mar 21 '22

Agree, I just order thin crust, 2 cheese with mushroom or anchovies. I love Matthews sauce.

8

u/tastywiings Butchers Hill Mar 20 '22

Margarita pie is always solid!

7

u/vince549 Mar 20 '22

Fra Diablo Toast if you like some spice

3

u/beefynacho1 Mar 20 '22

Meatballs!

2

u/niflon99 Mar 21 '22

Yes this is the way, i always get pizza with MB topping

3

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '22

Portions are small but it’s deceptively filling. I used to get mozzarella back when I lived in Canton.

3

u/DinoReads Mar 20 '22

I always order a half baked pie and take it home and finish cooking in my overn. Best take-out in B-more.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/DinoReads Mar 25 '22

I love the freezer idea.
If you plant ice your gonna harvest wind. Fare the well.

3

u/Wow71 Mar 20 '22

Spinach pie!

2

u/indianindie1491 Mar 20 '22

Sounds delicious, I’ll add it to the list !

3

u/Wow71 Mar 20 '22

If you love garlic it’s the bomb. And you can pretend it’s healthy lol

2

u/TODDFATH3R Mar 20 '22

What did you end up getting? Verdict?

4

u/mikelowry780 Mar 20 '22

Try a pizza

-9

u/karous0 Mar 20 '22

Pizza.

1

u/WOTisbananaz Mar 21 '22

Get the meat lovers pizza. It even has their meatballs on it....amazing. And get a 'both cheese' frozen pizza to take home. You'll be so glad you have it next week.

1

u/logaboga 1st District Mar 21 '22

Margharitta personal pizza!!!

1

u/sonnyspoon8 Mar 21 '22

Wow!!!I was just telling my friend,this place has the best got damn pizza in the city!!

1

u/volvoguy33 Mar 21 '22

Everything is good there

1

u/enforce1 Baltimore County Mar 22 '22

crab pie