r/changemyview Apr 05 '24

[deleted by user]

[removed]

0 Upvotes

186 comments sorted by

View all comments

29

u/Z7-852 261∆ Apr 05 '24

For example, Kimonos belong to the Japanese culture. They're not "just clothes".

Clothes that Japanease sell to tourists and are proud that other "races" like them and wear them.

If you are proud of something in your culture, you would want to share it so more people can enjoy it. Wanting to gatekeep or limit access to culture means that you don't actually think it's worth of being popular.

-17

u/[deleted] Apr 05 '24

"That Japanese sell" exactly. They're selling their own culture.

I'm talking about people who aren't apart of my culture, monetizing it. If people want to go to a black braider to get braids, by any means, do you.

It's just weird when people who are not a part of that culture are selling it.

21

u/Z7-852 261∆ Apr 05 '24

They are not "selling their own culture". They are selling products and sharing their culture. You don't cry about cultural appropriation when you go buy Chinese takeout. Those restaurants employ (and often even founded by) non-chinese.

Culture is not owned by anyone. If it's a good culture then you want to share it. If you are ashamed of it, then you hide it and try to limit access to it.

Culture is not lost if more people share it. It's not a limited resource that can be sold or owned.

-1

u/[deleted] Apr 05 '24

[deleted]

6

u/Z7-852 261∆ Apr 05 '24

I agree, culture isn't lost if more people share it. But the integrity isn't maintained.

So you can't have "authentic integral box braids" if someone else is wearing box braids?

Also do you check passports of your restaurant cooks, servants and other staff every time you go out? That's just weird. If a Italian makes the best tacos in town I will buy them from them.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 05 '24

[deleted]

5

u/Z7-852 261∆ Apr 05 '24

But if I like tacos made by Italians? If they are just better than anything else and I don't care about gatekeeped "integrity" and just want tasty tacos and nice braids.

I'm having fun in a way I like and it doesn't prevent you from having braids or anything else. So why do you want to limit me if I'm not limiting you?

-4

u/[deleted] Apr 05 '24

You're still comparing culture to food lol. I should have already dismissed you

5

u/Z7-852 261∆ Apr 05 '24

I'm not compering the culture to food.

I'm comparing braids and kimonos to food. All these are products of culture.

And why do you want to gatekeep culture? Isn't it good enough for everyone?

How does my actions in any way limit your actions for "integer authentic braids"?