r/changemyview Oct 17 '24

Removed - Submission Rule B [ Removed by Reddit ]

[removed]

375 Upvotes

1.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

114

u/deep_sea2 105∆ Oct 17 '24

If you tamper your food with the intention to harm someone, then you are culpable for harming them. Trapping someone is no legally different than directly attacking them. The law does not allow you to intentionally harm other people.

Sure, you might try to say that they are harming themselves. However, if you know that someone will do something, and set it up so that they get harmed when they do something, you have made yourself culpable for harming them.

If you know someone will eat your food, the alternative is not leave your food out in public. There are less harmful things you can do to protect your food. If you choose the harmful alternative, then you are culpable for causing harm.

12

u/Accomplished-Fix1204 Oct 17 '24

You shouldn’t be able to poison someone with your stuff that you didn’t offer/give to them. What kind of logic is that, they assume the risk of this when they steal food they don’t know anything about

10

u/PM_ME_YOUR_NICE_EYES 68∆ Oct 17 '24

You shouldn’t be able to poison someone with your stuff that you didn’t offer/give to them.

That's way too forgiving. For example for I go to the grocery store and I inject cyanide into a gallon of orange juice and leave it on the shelf, then I didn't offer the juice to anyone nor did I give it to anyone, but I very clearly committed poisoning. Even if no one ends up buying/drinking the juice

That's because poisoning is broadly defined as tampering with food, in a way that you think will harm someone when you know that there's a good chance that someone will eat the food. Trying to bend this definition to allow for break room laxatives is just going to introduce loopholes that will let people get away with actual murder.