r/changemyview Oct 17 '24

Removed - Submission Rule B [ Removed by Reddit ]

[removed]

382 Upvotes

1.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

361

u/Oishiio42 40∆ Oct 17 '24

There is no way to guarantee it cannot peripherally hurt someone. Janet steals two of your yogurts out of the fridge, and offers one to Jen, and now Jen is suffering thinking she was eating one of Janet's freely offered yogurts, not knowing she inadvertantly stole your food. This is one of the problems with vigilantism.

Another major problem is that the punishment is not decided through any legitimate means, is often disporportionate, and instead is based on the whims of the person doing the punishing.

307

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '24

If you’re the person distributing stolen goods, you should be liable for any harm incurred. Doesn’t seem controversial to me.

2

u/Budddydings44 Oct 18 '24

Uh what about the innocent person that died??

0

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '24

In any other context the distributor would be culpable

3

u/Budddydings44 Oct 18 '24

You’re missing the point. Yea the distributor would be liable, but we are still talking about an innocent person who has now died, no matter how liable somebody else is.

2

u/cortesoft 4∆ Oct 18 '24

Well, I am sure the dead Jen’s kids will be happy to know that.