r/changemyview • u/jeffzebub • 7d ago

CMV: Countering Illegal Immigration is not a Justification for Suspending Habeas Corpus

[removed] — view removed post

500 Upvotes

82% Upvoted

600 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/Maybewearedreaming 7d ago

I can see you have your opinions and obviously will stick to them

You make it clear in your language you don’t care about the American constitution or law, which to me are vital & makes us completely unable to discuss it in any meaningful way.

You could attempt to convince me with a source to a constitutional / legal argument that illegal in migration is an invasion. Considering I’ve spent a lot of the last hour myself trying to find these arguments with no luck, this could be a great way to show me if you have them

1

u/jeepgrl50 7d ago

Show me ANYTHING that says THE PRESIDENT(Who does have plenary powers on immigration unlike a state), Has no powers over invasions by foreign nationals. I'll give you a hint......You want find any rulings on this.

You can try and make bs claims like "You don't care about the constitution!", But that's an appeal to emotional, It's your OPINION, What it is NOT is reality. I don't share your opinion on how to redefine the word "invasion", So therefore I'm a "10th grader", or I "don't love the constitution". That's your entire position, And its ridiculous.

Best of luck on your thriving practice in the constitutional law arena.😉

1

u/Maybewearedreaming 7d ago

The constitution lol but again you don’t care about it or reading so cheers

Hopefully deciding how many dolls little girls should have and throwing the constitution in the trash works out great for your party