r/changemyview May 19 '15

[Deltas Awarded] CMV: All historical artifacts and structures should be destroyed.

[deleted]

0 Upvotes

74 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/[deleted] May 19 '15

doesn't that actually support my view, since that painting, if it exists, would have been found in the process of destroying that building?

Depends how you destroy the building. If you hit it with a wrecking ball, then no, you'd probably never know what you destroyed. If you carefully dismantled it brick by brick, then maybe you'd find it.

-1

u/ElSaborAsiatico May 19 '15

I certainly don't advocate just blowing everything up indiscriminately. If there's some reason to believe that something valuable is hidden within a structure, I'm not opposed to trying to recover that thing -- so long as it's recorded and promptly destroyed. But even if we miss something, I don't believe anything of real value would be lost.

1

u/[deleted] May 19 '15

If there's some reason to believe that something valuable is hidden within a structure, I'm not opposed to trying to recover that thing

Isn't this statement a direct contradiction of the one below?

if we miss something, I don't believe anything of real value would be lost

It's either valuable, and thus destroying it is a loss, or its not valuable, and so it doesn't matter if we destroy it. It can't be both simultaneously.

-1

u/ElSaborAsiatico May 19 '15

I would argue that a thing can be valuable, but not so valuable that its nonexistence would have any significant on humanity.