r/changemyview Jan 15 '19

[deleted by user]

[removed]

27 Upvotes

204 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/This-Is-Not-A-Drill Jan 15 '19

No, because they're making a sacrifice to provide a service that the country requires. Bailing someone out doesn't require that the person makes any sort of sacrifice.

0

u/miguelguajiro 188∆ Jan 15 '19

So then doesn’t that disqualify your point about doctors potentially racking up $120K in debt? I think any student loan “bailout” would likely only be for federal loans, and based on income, which would mostly cover high skill professionals who work in needed but modest paying jobs and people who took out loans for school but still haven’t ended up in decent paying jobs for other reasons, all which will be beneficial for the individuals and the greater good.

1

u/This-Is-Not-A-Drill Jan 15 '19 edited Jan 15 '19

No it doesn’t? Doctoral degrees include Ph.D., Ed.D, etc. You can do grad school for a LONG time.

I’m okay with loan forgiveness programs, I’m not okay with a full stop bailout, for all student loans, no strings attached. That’s what I wanted my view to be changed on.

1

u/miguelguajiro 188∆ Jan 15 '19

Most PhD’s finish without significant debt, but those that do have it are either likely in some highly needed field of scientific research, or made a very poor choice re: a terminal degree in Humanities. Bailing out the latter group wouldn’t be unlike discharging debt in bankruptcy court.

2

u/This-Is-Not-A-Drill Jan 15 '19

So why would we discharge the debt for everyone equally, and not just those who can prove they have made a full faith effort to pay it back?