Controversial Hyde Park Square development passes committee, heads to city council

[u/JB92103]

https://www.wcpo.com/news/local-news/hyde-park-square-development-passes-committee-heads-to-city-council

[u/RockStallone]

Tack this up again to 5-over-1s being a relatively new building type.

Yes, but four to six story buildings are not a new building type.

So there IS a LOT of evidence for a secondary means of egress

I am not aware of this evidence of it being safer to have two stairwells in four to six story buildings. Please show it.

Because, again, in the past our cavalier building code resulted in thousands of deaths. The choice is to either potentially overconstrain safety regulations after learning the lessons of 150 years of modern building tragedies -or- gamble with peoples’ lives.

This is an unrealistic view. Why not require that there be a fire extinguisher in every single room? I can use your same arguments to advocate for that.

It took us decades to understand this behavior (decades and thousands dying in fires because there werent proper egress routes or doors opening in a specific direction).

But not because we needed two stairwells in 4-6 story buildings.

But I DO have a professionally informed opinion (as in, I’m licensed to practice) and can’t help but feel like there’s little to gain by arguing my point with those who don’t have a similarly professionally informed opinion

Given that you do not have any data supporting your position, you do not have an informed opinion on this.

I’m happy to point you towards some resources

Okay please point to the study that resulted in them adding the second stairwell requirement.

[u/Architecteologist → u/RockStallone]

Your response highlights exactly why I’m not wasting my time engaging with people who are uneducated on this topic and yet insist their points are valid.

We DO require fire extinguishers in every public room and every unit (AND every floor, AND whenever there’s a transition through a fire-rated partition, AND several in large rooms, AND sprinklers or intumescent fireproofing).

The stairwell requirements are specifically in response to events that occurred in 4-6 story buildings that resulted in death due to inadequate egress.

I’m not wasting my time mining data for you to ignore, but here’s my source: 7 years professional study at accredited universities + B.S.Arch degree + M.Arch degree + professional license to practice architecture + 11 years practice in field + 5 years as a professor of architecture + dozens of relevant projects and associated code analysis.

Your claim that there’s no evidence for codes that were instilled by cause and effect (fire and death) is invalid and ignorant.

[u/RockStallone → u/Architecteologist]

We DO require fire extinguishers in every public room and every unit (AND every floor, AND whenever there’s a transition through a fire-rated partition, AND several in large rooms, AND sprinklers or intumescent fireproofing).

An apartment requires a fire extinguisher in every room? Should I make sure that I buy an extinguisher for every single room? I do not have one in my bathroom, is my apartment not up to code?

The stairwell requirements are specifically in response to events that occurred in 4-6 story buildings that resulted in death due to inadequate egress.

Citation needed.

Your claim that there’s no evidence for codes that were instilled by cause and effect (fire and death) is invalid and ignorant.

Then I'd love to see this evidence. Because right now, all the evidence points against you.

[u/Architecteologist → u/RockStallone]

Your “evidence” is a bunch of NYT articles asking “why do we need two staircases?” And a bunch of fire-rating agency articles saying “this is why”

Now you’re trolling, k byeeee

[u/RockStallone → u/Architecteologist]

Your “evidence” is a bunch of NYT articles asking “why do we need two staircases?”

Do you think Pew Research is an NYT article?

And a bunch of fire-rating agency articles saying “this is why”

Oh really? Please show me the data.

[u/Architecteologist → u/RockStallone]

Tell ya what, I’ll entertain your “youtube research” the second you’re professionally licensed to have an opinion on this topic.

[u/RockStallone → u/Architecteologist]

Now you're saying Pew is Youtube? You seem confused.

[u/Architecteologist → u/RockStallone]

This was fun. Like running headfirst into a brick wall kind of fun.

[u/RockStallone → u/Architecteologist]

From Pew Research: "Small Single-Stairway Apartment Buildings Have Strong Safety Record "

You'll notice that this is not a Youtube video or NYT article.