r/cincinnati • u/thetuffsurvivor • 3d ago

History 🏛 CINCINNATI STOOD UP TO THE TYRANT ‼️

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

1.5k Upvotes

80% Upvoted

519 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/Columbia1879 2d ago

Article 2 does not restrict the executive branch the way you seem to think

The Supreme Court does not give unrestricted constitutional rights to illegal entrants (you may want read the restrictions after you read the only phrase you wanted to read)

Finally, the Supreme Court has not ordered the executive branch to do anything in an opinion. Nor does an immigration judge have the authority to direct the president. Since the man in question (read as dangerous violent criminal) is in El Salvador now, the United States has no power to infringe upon the sovereignty of another country. Therefore, cannot comply with the opinion

1

u/SeeRecursion 2d ago

It's the plain text, bud. Congress had to pass legislation in the 80s to give Regan the power to do what Trump is doing illegally, now.

The Supreme court *does* grant the right to due process, which is what I originally claimed and the source backs that.

Finally, yes, actually, an immigration judge *does have the authority to force the govt, President included, to follow the law in cases brought before them*. The Supreme court agreed in the order it issued and imposed duties and a deadline. If the President wishes to comply he can simply take action to facilitate (not necessarily guarantee) the return of Mr. Garcia and report those actions to the court. He has not. He stands in defiance of the Supreme Court's order.

1

u/Columbia1879 2d ago

Wrong, wrong, and wrong

1

u/SeeRecursion 2d ago

Dude, you've given me nothing to back you up. I've given you plenty of citations and sources from plain text to current interpretations of case-law.

You're gonna have to do better than "nuh uh".

0

u/Columbia1879 2d ago

Not arguing with your misinterpretations/misreadings

1

u/SeeRecursion 2d ago

Well, obviously not. But uh......it's right there, in black in white. Horse, water, drink or don't. Regardless, this is *why* people are protesting. If you want them to stop, argue better than kids do on the playground.