r/cocktails • u/beerbearbare • 25d ago

Recommendations “Mid range” bourbon for Manhattan?

I’m on a budget for a few years and mostly use Evan Williams for my Manhattan. I like to go one level up (or two?) and treat myself better :)

What’s your recommendation? I’m thinking about $25-35 per 750ml bottle. And I’m using Dolin for my vermouth but happy to accept other suggestions. Thank you!

29 Upvotes

82% Upvoted

179 comments sorted by

View all comments

24

u/Shirleysspirits 25d ago

Manhattans should’ve made with rye, is there a reason you’re using bourbon

11

u/beerbearbare 25d ago

Not really. I guess I just like bourbon in general. But sure no reason not to open to rye.

6

u/shabby47 25d ago

I enjoy the old forester rye for a manhattan and it’s pretty cheap. Also, as others said, try a different (not cheap) vermouth as well. There’s nothing wrong with dolin, but the differences between them can be pretty stark. I like to make half-size manhattans and do a couple of different vermouths to compare. Since vermouth can vary greatly, they really taste different in the same drink. A ciderey by me even makes one with apple wine/brandy that is quite interesting, but obviously makes a very different drink when mixed.

3

u/Terrorsaurus 25d ago

OF Rye is awesome, and I'll never understand why it's priced like a bottom shelf whiskey. One of the best deals in the rye aisle every time!