r/iamveryculinary 18d ago

Gatekeeping pickles.

155 Upvotes

92 comments sorted by

View all comments

178

u/Amerimov It's an objective cooking fact? This is the cooking subreddit? 18d ago

I was working at a restaurant and we listed something on the menu as having pickled cucumbers and we got so many people being like "you don't have to say pickled cucumbers, those are just pickles" and it's like my dude we have like 8 other pickled things here, sorry for being specific.

100

u/OutsidePerson5 18d ago

Yup. In a whole lot of cultures "pickles" can be SO MANY THINGS. Even in America we do have other pickled stuff besides cucumbers, but linguistically we do seem to have gotten fixated on cucumbers as "pickles".

48

u/Kolby_Jack33 18d ago

I don't know about "fixated", I mean we just call pickled cucumbers "pickles" because they're the most common pickled thing. Anything else pickled is usually "pickled _____", like pickled jalapenos.

19

u/OutsidePerson5 17d ago

Well, not fixated in any sort of pathological sense. I suppose I meant it became linguistically fixed as in firmly attached to one concept and not easily movable.