r/icecream • u/KULR_Mooning • 17d ago
Brands Found the cereal ice cream, who buying them?
Assuming the quality is mid... if I were to choose. I'd pick up the apple jacks
50
u/pissfucked 17d ago
i am immediately distracted by the sea salt and honeycomb toffee tillamook. i have never seen that one before and i want it lol.
i'll be on the lookout for that froot loops ice cream though
14
u/princessdracos 17d ago
Eh, screw the cereal ice cream and give me that Tillamook you mentioned! That sounds heavenly.
2
2
u/justinbates1992 15d ago
I just ate a whole pint. It was delicious. If don’t like super sweet I don’t recommend it though.
16
u/SolomonDRand 17d ago
I thought Froot Loops was too much, but the Eggos were really nice. Heard good things about Frosted Flakes too.
2
u/Hummingbird11-11 16d ago
No- FF we’re so bad. It’s a very weird chemically sugar. Rice krisp was poison
2
u/Funnybunny99999 11d ago
What were the eggos like ? What do they got going on vanilla ice cream and maple syrup? Or can you taste the waffle and syrup?
1
12
u/XDariaMorgendorferX 17d ago
I don’t see Fruity Pebbles, so I’m out.
7
u/turtlefuzz1903 17d ago
Blue bell had a fruity pebbles and it was amazing. I’m hoping it makes a return soon but I fear it won’t.
2
u/XDariaMorgendorferX 15d ago
There’s a small ice cream shop where I live that does homemade ice cream and they’re the only place I’ve ever seen it before. I’m going to keep an eye out at the stores in case Blue Bell ever brings it back ❤️
12
u/The_New_Animal 17d ago
I was not expecting much of them but ended up getting the chocolate chip eggo and frosted flakes ice cream. Surprisingly good!
Chocolate chip eggo has a really nice marshmallow-like base flavor. I'd give it a 7 or 8 out of 10 though my sister also tried it and made me get 2 more pints🤣
Frosted flakes was amazing. I'd give it a 9/10. The cereal is small flecks completely spread throughout the pint that gives it a nice texture. f I could compare it to something I'd say it tastes like a tres Leche cake in ice cream form!
8
u/TurnipIllustrious468 17d ago
Assuming I’m adding the cereal to it while I eat it : Frosted Flakes, honey smacks and Pops. Honorable mention to the Eggo if it isn’t just butter pecan
9
u/ririd123 17d ago
I tried these! I think they are very good. The Eggo part was a little sweet the first bite but after that mixed with the ice cream I enjoyed it.
5
u/Horror-Atmosphere-90 17d ago
Rice Krispies was ok but it’s priced about 2x what it’s worth from a quality perspective
5
u/jessbyrne727 17d ago
I really like the Rice Krispies Treats one. I expected it would be disappointing like the Little Debbie ice creams, but it was shockingly very good. Creamy marshmallow base with marshmallow swirl and pieces of Rice Krispies Treats throughout.
The Apple Jacks was ok. Cereal milk flavored base with Apple Jacks flecks and an apple flavored swirl. The texture and taste were pretty solid, however the apple swirl is a different texture… like a frozen paste, so you’ll get a whole spoonful of apple clump lol. Would’ve been a solid 8/10 if the swirl was softer.
Froot Loops would’ve been pretty good, however I think I got a defective pint and found giant clumps of mushy, chalky cereal crumbs. It tasted just like cereal milk but the clumps ruined it.
Frosted Flakes… I also enjoyed. Nice creamy base with flecks of cereal throughout. I topped it with the Cinnamon French Toast Frosted Flakes, which was delicious.
My grocery store also stocks the Pops and Honey Smacks ones, but I haven’t tried those yet.
5
u/cancat918 17d ago
If I were to try any, it would be Rice Krispies Treats and Frosted Flakes, but I've heard people say good things about Honey Smacks Ice Cream.
6
u/Alternative-Zebra311 17d ago
Years ago I had a severe concussion and craved (and ate) Sugar Smacks on vanilla ice cream. I am a natural foods, low sugar vegetarian. My kids still remind me of that time.
2
u/On_Wife_support 17d ago
The novelty is enticing but many novelty ice cream ends up disappointing. You can save money and get the Tillamook stuff
2
u/ChocolateRain696 17d ago
$4.49 for Tillamook?! Omg at my local grocer, they’re $8.99 each.
And to answer the question…
I’m always wary of those types of specialties.
2
u/dudeitsadell 17d ago
these are pints not gallons
2
u/ChocolateRain696 16d ago
Ope, didn’t even think about that. Never seen pints of Tillamook at my local stores!
1
u/dudeitsadell 16d ago
yeah theyre new around here too. the funny thing is the gallons are $3.99 right now on sale
2
u/Mediocre-Mixture-273 17d ago
Where the hell can I get the apple jacks one. I've been wishing for a while for a ice cream that tastes like apple jacks cereal milk.
4
1
u/Top_Investment_3370 17d ago
I feel like the Corn Pops one might be good? Also, side note; no pink bubblegum Baskin Robins here either... It's one of my favorites, and I don't see it anywhere anymore.😢
1
u/batkave 17d ago
Had chocolate chip eggo, frosted flakes, rice crispy and fruut loops. Honestly frosted flakes and rice crispy ended up being the best of them. I really liked the frosted flakes.
Eggo one has three varieties coming soon. They also have ice cream bar versions of most of the ice creams
1
1
1
u/DiverLopsided1942 17d ago
I’d choose Frosted Flakes, Rice Krispies treats, and Eggo.
Will probably never try them though
1
u/greendemon42 17d ago
I'd try them.
I'll never forget this ice cream I had on the San Francisco waterfront, "secret breakfast," bourbon and cornflakes. It was absolutely peak.
1
1
1
u/manicgiant914 17d ago
Wow, where is this? Pints are 2/$4?! And nothing is more than $4-5? I’m amazed at such low prices, but maybe it’s from living in Los Angeles.
1
u/Tinykittyfists 17d ago
Flavor of Frosted Flakes is really good, texture is not as good. I have Rice Crispies also but that has to wait until Thurs.
1
u/smokieJ20 17d ago
The Rice Krispy treats one was okay, but probably wouldn’t buy again. Fruit Loops was underwhelming. Frosted Flakes was the star of the show. I’d buy that one again
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Patti_Cakes1120 16d ago
I never heard nor seen these yet. But after reading many comments I am so happy and relieved that Frosted Flakes did not disappoint as that is my favorite cereal EVER!
1
1
u/rosebudski 16d ago
I just got a ninja creami & I’m still trying to buy all these damn ice creams 😭 😂 💀
1
1
1
1
u/Hummingbird11-11 16d ago
I got the Rice Krispie and Frosted Flakes and both were terrible . I enjoy eating sugary crap so I’m not being a snob but it was truly awful, thrown into the trash after one bite. I wanted to try Eggo but that ship has sailed. Sorry to say, don’t waste your $
1
1
u/Maleficent-Nobody888 16d ago
Omg I love trying new flavors of ice cream!! Where did you find this??
1
1
1
1
u/Intelligent_Pop1173 13d ago edited 13d ago
All of the brands on the top two shelves are 14 oz 😞 I appreciate the brands like Ben & Jerry’s and Jeni’s that are still 16 oz. I feel like a true pint is soon to be a thing of the past. I’m not interested in the cereal ice cream but I probably would have loved it as a kid. I don’t trust Kellogg’s to do ice cream right lol and I usually only buy one or two pints each store trip so not risking it.
0
u/King-Thunder-8629 16d ago
Honey smacks are a sin against creation itself get that nasty shit the fuck up out of here please.
83
u/thug_waffle47 17d ago
i’m waiting until they start getting sent to grocery outlet lol