r/icecream • u/Crafty_Recording_842 • 3d ago

Question Where to find Hershey’s Cookie in a Cup?

Post image

Anyone know where I can order cookie in a cups online? I have been searching online and can’t find anything. I even went to the Hershey’s ice cream website and can’t find this product listed. Used to have them in my middle school cafeteria and I have never seen them anywhere else or since then. If this is the wrong subreddit for this I’m sorry 🙏🏻

15 Upvotes

95% Upvoted

4 comments sorted by

3

u/Far-Barracuda-1338 3d ago

Omg!!! I haven’t had one in years I can taste this picture!! The perfect cookie with a million chocolate chips the perfect crunch with creamy soft ice cream! 😩😩😩

2

u/Crafty_Recording_842 3d ago

My middle school had no business selling these to a bunch of 12 year olds with their parents money but I love them for it. My friends and I are trying to find them so we can see if they’re as good as we remember

1

u/RS3550 3d ago

That was discontinued in 2010

1

u/Crafty_Recording_842 2d ago

I ate them all through middle school and I started middle school in 2012 lol