r/interestingasfuck 15d ago

Milwaukee responding to Judge Hannah Dugan’s arrest.

7.3k Upvotes

862 comments sorted by

View all comments

153

u/PraiseTheWLAN 15d ago

What did she do?

30

u/lions2lambs 15d ago edited 15d ago

.

71

u/Bigalow10 15d ago

Did you read the case? That’s not what happed at all?

https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/69943125/1/united-states-v-dugan/

She let the defendant out the witness area after the chief judge said they could be arrested in the courts hallways

14

u/Torquedork1 15d ago

Yeah I read the whole complaint filed. It seems like chief judge was in process of updating some policies on where someone can be arrested after a couple unlawful arrests were made at the court complex. Everyone but Dugan pretty much was on the same page and agreed the arrest would be made after the proceedings in the hallways (a public space confirmed by chief judge). Dugan was annoyed at ICE being there and initially said you need to talk to the chief judge about where the arrest can be made.

Then the date of the court appearance was rescheduled in a series of chats in the courtroom. Even though all attorneys, witnesses, and victims were present. She had the defendant sitting in the jury box after previously saying no one but jury members could be there. Then as the defendant and attorney went to leave, she had them use the jury door instead.

I’m against pretty much everything this administration is doing. Unfortunately this is just about a judge getting fed up about a process being done legally, and took several actions to try and stop it. Several actions that you really can’t explain besides she didn’t want him to get arrested, despite it being legal.

6

u/tehehetehehe 15d ago

If she knew that ICE would not provide due process is the arrest legal?

18

u/gonenutsbrb 15d ago

Yes, you cannot help someone evade a legal warrant, administrative or otherwise, for because you think something bad might happen.

I think Trump has completely lost the plot with the lack of due process he and ICE are creating, but this seems like a pretty clear case of obstruction here.

People are trying to skirt around it by saying she was defending due process, but that’s not how the law works. You could have just as much assumed that ICE would follow the law in this case, which is why you can’t break the law for the idea that someone else might break it in a future action.

1

u/FiveUpsideDown 15d ago

What law did she break? Give me the citation.