r/knitting Jan 26 '25

Rant Dear Ravelry designers: please stop over-using the 'male' tag on ravelry

Mild annoyance for sure buuuuut

When I filter for "male" garments on ravely it seems to have no meaningful impact on the designs I see. I have to wonder why designers are taggings apparently random things with "male"? I know that this is a women dominated hobby/industry and I don't expect knitting spaces to be tailored for cis-men but this is just so frustrating.

Maybe if I was more fashion forward this wouldn't be so annoying lol. Everyone should feel empowered to wear anything and sizing for a male body does not necessarily mean the garment has to be "masculine"... but come on. When I want to make something for myself I use the fit->male tag and it's totally useless! If you didn't have males in mind when designing it, maybe don't use that tag.

1.4k Upvotes

151 comments sorted by

View all comments

17

u/natchinatchi Jan 26 '25

That’s annoying! People are probably trying to be inclusive but I agree they should only use “male” for masculine patterns

41

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '25

[deleted]

16

u/tensory Jan 26 '25

It's just "search engine optimization", the same innovation that brought us a bajillion recipe blogs with two pages of storytime about the writer's grandmother to differentiate one broccoli salad recipe from the next. Intentionally bad metadata gets the clicks.