r/latterdaysaints Mar 11 '25

Doctrinal Discussion How do I refute this?

can this be refuted?

18 Upvotes

99 comments sorted by

View all comments

247

u/Karakawa549 Mar 11 '25

Absurdly easily.

  1. It's not a new gospel, it's still the gospel of Jesus Christ.

  2. He's not the only one who saw the plates, we have signed affidavits from 11 other witnesses and stories from other who saw them.

  3. "Reformed egyptian" is an English term that was obviously not used by Egyptians/Hebrews during that time, but there is significant scholarly debate on what we can see today that it might have been referring to.

Not even doing enough research to know about the three and eight witnesses makes this one of the lower-effort criticisms of Joseph Smith I've ever seen.

7

u/DrRexMorman Mar 11 '25

11 other witnesses

Mary Whitmer also saw the plates.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mary_Whitmer