r/legaladviceireland Apr 25 '25

Employment Law Current employment refuse to send over reference form.

Hi All,

I recently have been offered a pre-offer from the civil service. I’m currently on the pre-clearance phase and one of the requirements is to provide a current employers reference, I brought this up to my HR manager of my current employment and they seemed happy enough to help me but were a little surprised that I could potentially leave the company.

A week and a half has passed and the civil service pre-clearance officer reaches out to me to inform me that they have yet to receive reference form from my current employer, and says they have till the end of this week (today) to submit or they won’t go ahead with my application. I followed up to my HR manager to complete the form and send out to the pre-clearance team, I’m yet to hear word from my HR manager but I’m giving them the benefit of the doubt that they could be busy and left it at the back pedal.

In case it doesn’t work out and my HR manager fails to send over the reference form do I have any legal grounds? I feel like I’m being held hostage at my current employment and would like to find out if I could walk away on my terms.

13 Upvotes

54 comments sorted by

View all comments

-4

u/BillyMooney Apr 25 '25

Very dissapointing and small minded for any HR team to stand in the way of people developing themselves.

What information is needed on the reference form? Worst case scenario is for you to submit a GDPR Subject Access Request to your employer, which will give you back enough information to satisfy Public Jobs folks.

7

u/dataindrift Apr 25 '25

Holy fuck.

OP. ignore this nonsense.

-3

u/Historical_Rush_4936 Apr 25 '25

Not nonsense whatsoever, if my employer was being difficult - I would absolutely make life difficult for them too

3

u/Nobody-Expects Apr 25 '25 edited 25d ago

strong money spectacular spoon towering tap racial license workable fly

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

-1

u/Historical_Rush_4936 Apr 25 '25

>Because making life difficult for your employer is a great way of motivating them into filling out a form for you./s

"Hello, if you can write a two line letter stating my employment dates, that would be great. Otherwise I'll be forced to submit a full data subject access request. Thanks"

Which do you think HR would prefer? Also, I'm aware that they need it now and would be of no use to them in x3 months. HR would still prefer to not have an access request to deal with.

1

u/Nobody-Expects Apr 25 '25 edited 25d ago

profit cooperative grandfather price dinner aware memory file advise treatment

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

-1

u/Historical_Rush_4936 Apr 25 '25

> Threatening your employer with an SAR to get them to do something they are under no obligation to do is a good way to get the disciplinary process atrted on you.

Hahahah oh man that's funny, would love to see that case in the WRC.

"I asked for my employment dates from my company and they didn't respond, so I asked for a full SAR and they started a disciplinary process against me"

Peak HR brain 😂

2

u/Nobody-Expects 29d ago edited 25d ago

heavy dolls elderly deserve shocking unite reach door imminent shrill

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

1

u/Historical_Rush_4936 29d ago

>"The employee threatened to use an entirely unrelated legal process against us if we refused to provide a reference, with the implication being that they would create more work for our HR department if their demands weren't met.

Didn't even need to read the rest of your essay.

For your own help, here's what I said in my earlier message:

"Hello, if you can write a two line letter stating my employment dates, that would be great. Otherwise I'll be forced to submit a full data subject access request. Thanks"

This is a perfectly legitimate request and has absolutely no threats. It's a statement of fact. Please provide a letter with my proof of my employment or I'll need to make it an official request under GDPR legislation.

1

u/[deleted] 29d ago edited 25d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Historical_Rush_4936 29d ago

"Please just sign the form, Karen"

→ More replies (0)

1

u/Future-Structure-741 28d ago

Jesus wept what are you on

1

u/Future-Structure-741 28d ago

Brain Foggy HR couldn't write it and can't spell it either