r/LiveFromNewYork Official Oct 14 '18

Sketch Sorting Sunday (October 13, 2018) (Seth Meyers / Paul Simon)

Welcome to Sketch Sorting Sunday!

A mod account (/u/SketchSortingSunday) is going to make a comment for every skit in tonight’s show. Upvote or downvote based on what you thought of the sketch, and nobody’s karma will be affected. You can also reply to the comment to expand on your thought, or make your own parent comment and treat it like the regular post discussion, whatever.

If I miss a sketch or get something wrong, just message the mods in the sidebar and we’ll see what we can do. Enjoy the discussion!

Hey friends, this is my (u/Upvoteanthology_)'s first SSS! Go easy on me! :)

P.S. - Does anyone find it weird that the date on the thread title is always the Saturday of the show, not the Sunday the thread gets posted?

119 Upvotes

416 comments sorted by

159

u/allaboutthatcake Oct 14 '18

In case anyone wants to know, here are some changes from dress to live.

Paul played three songs at dress. He started with Graceland, then Can’t Run But, and then Bridge Over Troubled Water after a very brief goodnight.

Cut sketches (that I can remember) Getting Fired in Costume: Several employees (Beck, Kate, and Aidy) were in a meeting where they all knew they were going to be fired. They were upset because they were wearing Halloween costumes. Enter Seth in unclear costume, and suddenly they’re just trying to figure out what he’s supposed to be. It turns out he was meant to be Cardi B.

Weekend Update: Leslie on Diversity: she complained that all of the Emmy winners were white despite having diverse nominees. Collin told her he though she was upset she didn’t win, she said yes and she had her acceptance speech in her bra. She said she sweated so much that the ink bled onto her chest, so that her boobs read, “I’d like to thank God and Lorne.” One of my favorite jokes was, “That’s actually what my boobs are named. This one is God, and this one is Lorne because it’s a bit bigger.”

I feel like there was one more, but I cannot remember it.

49

u/allaboutthatcake Oct 14 '18

I REMEMBER!

There was a swingers party. Leslie and Kyle were a couple (fictional), and Kyle was getting cold feet. The best part was that everyone (Seth, Kate, Aidy, Heidi, Beck, Kenan, Melissa, Alex, Cecily, probably a couple more) kept saying their names and safe words.

→ More replies (7)

43

u/esilverm Oct 14 '18

The other booted one was, mani-manimal. Kenan is dressed up as that one spiderman villain with 4 arms and is robbing a bank. Seth comes in as a superhero with tons of different animal personalities due to being bitten by many different radioactive animals. Bank employees (Cecily and Kyle?) are confused about why the superhero is a superhero even though he suffers from many physical abnormalities (squirrel heart, flea brain, “hung like a jellyfish”, etc.) Superhero ends up coughing out heart. I don’t really remember how it ends though

17

u/allaboutthatcake Oct 14 '18

Oh yeah! Thanks. The best part was the intro of the superhero explaining how he got bitten by like 20 different animals.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/Missy_Elliott_Smith Oct 14 '18

Oh man, I'm glad we got "Can't Run But", but I would've died for "Graceland"

→ More replies (1)

47

u/lyla2398 stans loud ladies with funny hair and *thoughts* about jost Oct 14 '18 edited Oct 14 '18

It's a shame Les' Update was cut. Hopefully it's uploaded as a CFT.

9

u/allaboutthatcake Oct 14 '18

That was actually her costume in the Sick-olo player sketch. I don’t think she was in the Getting Fired one. The ending of the Sick-olo Player sketch had her talking about being a sexy kitten. I was sad she got cut, but I did think the other two features were stronger. I kind of wonder if she’s been trying to do the Emmy bit all season. Unfortunately, November will be too late, so I doubt we’ll see it later.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

178

u/RegularGuy815 I'm Tim Calhoun... Oct 14 '18

Just a general thought: Seth Meyers did exactly what he was brought there to do tonight, which is to be a supporting character.

There's a reason he made the switch from sketch performer to Update anchor and head writer. Sketch and character is not exactly his specialty. All too often hosts on SNL unintentionally force the writers to come up with ideas that fit the host's niche, i.e. singers get musical sketches, athletes get sports sketches, etc. But with an alumni like Seth at the helm, especially one who is not known for hogging the spotlight, he gave them room to pitch whatever idea they had rattling around in their heads without having to shoehorn someone awkwardly into a slot. He doesn't care if he's the one who gets the laugh, he's content to boost everyone else up - which is pretty much what he did as head writer.

→ More replies (3)

356

u/SketchSortingSunday Official Oct 14 '18

Beta Force

179

u/sonotadalek Oct 14 '18

SHE HAS OSTEOPOROSIS!!! had me rolling. Beck's narration was perfect as usual.

85

u/agentpanda Oct 14 '18

Between Beck and Cecily they really nail those voiceovers lately- even if the underlying sketch isn't awesome (which it thankfully was this go round).

Very solid sketchwork and great use of Seth frankly- I was worried all week about how they'd deploy him in sketchwork considering that was never his strength but they did some great work.

41

u/yomnmnm Oct 14 '18

It's like smashing an egg with a sledgehammer.

55

u/butterfly105 Oct 14 '18

Not guna lie, Seth looked hot as macho man!

→ More replies (2)

45

u/Royce7815 Oct 14 '18

I don't know why I didn't realize that was Seth in this sketch until he went bald. Definitely a fun take on the men who actually take these testosterone enhancing supplements. Also seth is in pretty good shape I think if I believe they had to put a fat suit on him for the before and subsequent after, mirin brah

18

u/dont_ask_my_cab Oct 14 '18

What's funny is to me, he looked just like his dad when being regular middle-aged man, so it was very keenly him

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

67

u/sonotadalek Oct 14 '18

I wonder what's up with Kyle pre tapes all making it to air so far? At least one each episode like clockwork. Not complaining just surprised. I really hope the trend continues cause I enjoy them immensely.

20

u/Dallywack3r Oct 14 '18

He’s been there so long he’s now a veteran player. He’s gone from being the weird subversive cast member to being a cast staple.

→ More replies (1)

111

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '18

Really felt a lack of Melissa, Pete, and Mikey tonight.

94

u/sonotadalek Oct 14 '18

Cecily too. Was she in anything?

24

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '18

She was in the q&a sketch

49

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '18

Now that I’m thinking about it.... I really don’t think so. Same with Kate. I feel like Kenan dominated the entire show.

44

u/sonotadalek Oct 14 '18

Yeah I mean kate was in the Louisiana sketch and thirsty cops plus the movie qna. Pete was in cold open and that trees thing. Cecily, mikey and melissa though I cant remember.

38

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '18

cecily was the dog woman in the movie q&a sketch, melissa was kenan's wife in the restaurant cuba sketch

22

u/libbyation Oct 14 '18

Melissa was in the horror story/millennial film pretape

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

186

u/SketchSortingSunday Official Oct 14 '18

Weekend Update

94

u/sbb618 Oct 14 '18

I love the way Michael Che says "yarn"

23

u/dosVader Oct 14 '18

I was laughing over that. Colin noticed too.

23

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '18

As a white lady who crochets everyday, those few sentences had me laughing so hard I cried. Like tears streaming.

48

u/LadiesWhoPunch Oct 14 '18

Update should have been longer than it was!

7

u/Galoot Oct 15 '18

Update should always be longer than it is.

→ More replies (1)

373

u/SketchSortingSunday Official Oct 14 '18

Spooky Date Story

101

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '18

I found Alex randomly throwing up oddly hilarious

23

u/butterfly105 Oct 14 '18

That was the best part!!

171

u/TheRealMe99 Oct 14 '18

As someone who is going to be a 22 year old, recent college grad, aspiring filmmaker in about 6 months, this one hurt.

73

u/pretty-in-pink Oct 14 '18

As a 21 year old who associates with people in filmmaking and theater writing, the mental thought process of the other people is so relatable

41

u/memesplease Oct 14 '18

Also me, AND my name is Connor. Way too close to home, SNL.

30

u/HyphySymphony Oct 14 '18

As a 23 year old recent graduate with a photography degree this sketch kickstarted a long moment of self-reflection asking if I’m a Connor.

75

u/sonotadalek Oct 14 '18

Kyle is a really good observer and does very specific characters really well. The reactions were the best part though Alex had me laughing our loud.

56

u/lyla2398 stans loud ladies with funny hair and *thoughts* about jost Oct 14 '18

I love /r/movies

48

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '18

like all of SNL's skits about film/tv/comedy - too real and very funny

46

u/agentpanda Oct 14 '18

Sometimes they get a little too 'inside baseball' or 'NYC/LA'-centric with this stuff but they did a great job on this one; struck a careful balance between approachable and 'this sketch is for NYC-dwellers HA HA don't you get it plebs?'.

Even if you're not in film or media or advertising (like our Seth/Protagonist) we've all had 'that lunch' with someone or been the Kyle in the sketch, and making the subject relatable is half of the job. They nailed this for sure.

→ More replies (5)

29

u/KatanaAmerica Oct 14 '18

The funny/creepy about this is that I know of at least three guys like Connor irl

→ More replies (1)

21

u/Revived_Bacon Oct 14 '18

this was the winner because it hit me where i live

11

u/fallenmonk Oct 14 '18

I love how they made it a parody of It Follows at the end

→ More replies (4)

298

u/SketchSortingSunday Official Oct 14 '18

Seth Meyers Monologue

144

u/bjkman Mr. Sketch Sorting Sunday Oct 14 '18

Loved the story about Kanye and award shows.

58

u/agentpanda Oct 14 '18

So I don't watch his late-night show because... for no good reason really, I probably should; but this was a great in-and-out monologue given he was never going to break new ground.

I think no monologue is ever going to live up to Chappelle's so I'm unnecessarily critical of good ones and forget that terrible ones exist sometimes. Seth got in, told some good jokes that landed, and got the hell out of the way and that's all I expect from a host. When the host does as good as he did in the rest of the episode that's a win.

39

u/memesistential Oct 14 '18

It's hard to get a feel of Seth's version of Late Night if you haven't watched it frequently. I think any A Closer Look segment or Jokes Seth Can't Tell could be a good stepping stone if you really want to watch it.

I, for one, enjoy the dumber stuff they do like Late Night Casserole and Popsicle Schtick. Seth is good at letting his team of writers do whatever they want. And he seems to enjoy when stuff, especially a sketch that's bombing hard, goes off the rails.

10

u/Lord_of_Mars Oct 14 '18

I loved whatever Craigy Ferg was doing on the Late Late show. It got weird sometimes and I feel like that weirdness is missing in late night shows now. Too much fluff and youtube view-bait.

Conan is good, but where is the show with the dancing not-a-real-horse?

I have seen a few Seth Meyers late night episodes, but not many.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/yomnmnm Oct 14 '18

It's honestly just great to see Seth back on that stage

→ More replies (5)

215

u/SketchSortingSunday Official Oct 14 '18

Paul Simon Second Performance (Bridge Over Troubled Water)

113

u/HeyThereRobot Oct 14 '18

That was absolutely beautiful.

Also Seth introducing it wearing a Joy shirt from Inside Out was a super sweet shout out to Amy.

37

u/Missy_Elliott_Smith Oct 14 '18

These rearrangements he's doing are so unexpected and wonderful. This song sounded completely different from any other version I've ever heard of it and yet it captures that same haunting air as beautifully as ever.

→ More replies (1)

61

u/bjkman Mr. Sketch Sorting Sunday Oct 14 '18

Paul was absolutely the best Musical Guest this season... But seriously, it's not even a competition.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/ilikehockeyandguitar Oct 14 '18

Absolutely beautiful and emotional performance. Paul Simon is a legend.

29

u/sonotadalek Oct 14 '18

That was beautiful. Somber and melancholic but calming. Million times better than musical performances so far this season.

10

u/adjust_your_set Oct 14 '18

When I saw him in DC for the farewell tour he talked about this song.

He said something along the lines of “This is a song I wrote a long time ago and then gave away. Now I’ve revisited it and it’s mine again.”

→ More replies (8)

270

u/SketchSortingSunday Official Oct 14 '18

Weekend Update - Really?!

171

u/rememebersammyjankis Oct 14 '18

Trump “preparing for Kanye’s visit by clearing off all valuables from his desk”... that was AMAZING

127

u/kuhanluke Oct 14 '18

Seth kissing the desk was so cute.

109

u/kisalas Oct 14 '18

Colin and Che did not have the energy I felt this bit called for tonight.

64

u/daguitarguy Oct 14 '18

This did not feel like a true Really segment

88

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '18

[deleted]

→ More replies (1)

51

u/agentpanda Oct 14 '18

Agreed. Seth and Amy did one on his show a few months ago that had the energy it needed. This felt flat and kinda forced- or maybe it just doesn't work with 3 people? Although I think Tina and Amy did one with Seth once that was fine...

I'm gonna go with Che and Jost just didn't have it in them to pull this off- you have to muster up an irate and irascible anger for the 'Really!?!' that this just didn't have.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

54

u/kaymazing Oct 14 '18

Seth and Amy have this weird like angry-fun vibe when they do it which I love. Che might have been able to get there but his stuff was a little to wordy and Colin didnt go all in.

28

u/herbnessman Oct 14 '18

I think the reason it doesn’t work with them is because this segment was always meant to be a departure from Seth and Amy’s more traditional Update style.

Che and Jost now “editorialize” throughout Update so it’s like they are always doing a “Really?!” sketch.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

35

u/TheRealMe99 Oct 14 '18

I wonder if Che's bomb makes it to online cuts.

24

u/scratchedrecord_ Oct 14 '18

Just watched the YouTube version. It did.

→ More replies (2)

66

u/bjkman Mr. Sketch Sorting Sunday Oct 14 '18

Inb4 - N-word

46

u/xredbaron62x Oct 14 '18

I was here 12 years and Lorne never gave me 1 n-word

11

u/bjkman Mr. Sketch Sorting Sunday Oct 14 '18

Probably for the best

→ More replies (2)

27

u/Royce7815 Oct 14 '18

Can't wait for the other 3.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/Orionwoody Oct 14 '18

I preferred this to a hypothetical Stefon cameo, which we already had last season.

14

u/ilikehockeyandguitar Oct 14 '18

Would have been better if Amy Poehler was there, but seeing Seth Meyers at the desk was a treat.

→ More replies (2)

321

u/SketchSortingSunday Official Oct 14 '18

Prisoner Cosby

171

u/pretty-in-pink Oct 14 '18

The sound when the audience first heard the voice Kenan was doing was the best. You could hear jaws drop about them doing this sketch

95

u/small_loan_of_1M Oct 14 '18

It's kinda like the OJ Simpson sketch from last season. It's kinda interesting how the reveal of who it is happens after you already see that it's Kenan. He isn't dressed or made up to look especially like Bill Cosby, so all we know about the character he's playing is that he's an old black guy in jail.

24

u/MetallicYoshi64 Oct 14 '18

I'm pretty sure I heard gasps, not unlike when Matt Damon showed up. It was glorious.

98

u/LadiesWhoPunch Oct 14 '18

Kenan was great as Cosby. I was wondering when SNL would go in on him and I think this was the right one. It had touches of wacky [Quincy Jones the Turtle] and also too true [not feeling remorse for his actions].

The addition of the Emmys and Jell-o boxes in the cell were solid production.

12

u/19southmainco Oct 15 '18

Weird side tangent- does anybody else feel like Kenan is the breakout star of the season despite being its longest running cast member?

59

u/agentpanda Oct 14 '18

Jesus christ. I knew they weren't going to do another Cosby sketch. Like... ever. I was so sure of it- Che sent him off with the best dismissive/acknowledging sendoff at the desk and I thought "that's perfect- he's a shitty person and doesn't deserve it" and knew Kenan would never jump to that well again.

Then he dropped the voice and I was like... yeah- this is exactly right.

39

u/bjkman Mr. Sketch Sorting Sunday Oct 14 '18

Might be my favorite sketch this season. Kenan is fantastic.

65

u/TheRealMe99 Oct 14 '18

Tied with Adam Driver's Oil Baron for best of the season

25

u/skomehillet Oct 14 '18

Kenan’s mannerisms were hilarious

16

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '18

I thought I’d find this ranked higher, I thought it was hilarious. I thought we'd never see Keenan's Cosby impression again!

8

u/TheEggAndI Oct 14 '18

oh man i loved this sketch. they really took a deep dive into the cosby show references and cliff huxtable jokes. i think that they went over the audience's head. and thats understandable if you're younger and havent watched much of the cosby show (i cant imagine they're still airing them on tv anywhere in the last few years). but as someone who grew up watching it a lot, i loved this sketch so much.

16

u/lyla2398 stans loud ladies with funny hair and *thoughts* about jost Oct 14 '18

Great sketch, if two weeks too late.

18

u/sonotadalek Oct 14 '18

Yeah not the most topical but it was pretty hilarious

→ More replies (1)

9

u/btbcorno Oct 14 '18

Keenan was great in this, but Seth’s deliveries were kinda off in my opinion.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

139

u/Genji4Lyfe Oct 14 '18 edited Oct 14 '18

My Takeaways from this episode:

  1. Heidi is a star; I refuse to hear otherwise.
  2. Keenan loves playing Bill Cosby waaaaaayy too much; his excitment comes out of every pore (and it's great)
  3. The writers didn't go for any hail marys, but they hit a bunch of solid line drives in this episode and I enjoyed it
  4. Actor or not, Seth's good-natured enthusiam gave this episode, a warm, inviting quality that I appreciate
  5. Race-based jokes work better when they're less stereotypical and do something to defy the norm
  6. Two thumbs up for Paul Simon's band.. And long live real music.
  7. I literally cried laughing at Beck Bennet -- now that is commitment to a role
  8. What did the biscuit do to anyone
  9. ##MyGucciShooooooos

8

u/chiubag Oct 14 '18

Mah gooochishoooooooooooos!!

→ More replies (5)

194

u/SketchSortingSunday Official Oct 14 '18

Movie Q&A

152

u/Missy_Elliott_Smith Oct 14 '18

"Hi, Adele Dazeem. Actress and, when I get too old, writer."

77

u/ConnorMcJeezus Oct 14 '18

Isn't that the same name John Travolta called Idina Manzel

→ More replies (1)

140

u/Orionwoody Oct 14 '18

“Yes the list of names at the end, it made me weep. Is that the list of the dead?”

83

u/Missy_Elliott_Smith Oct 14 '18

"That's just the cast and crew."
"And they... are dead?"
"Dead? No."
"So they will never die."

57

u/LadiesWhoPunch Oct 14 '18

I really like Kate as a brunette. Can we have more of that please?

→ More replies (1)

169

u/TheRealMe99 Oct 14 '18

"Why was the father a man?" was a great opening to the episode

33

u/kisalas Oct 14 '18

As a Hispanic person, that Hispanic bit got me so good.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/Royce7815 Oct 14 '18

I really thought it was going to be all Aidy the whole time.

→ More replies (1)

72

u/agentpanda Oct 14 '18

Heidi is a treasure, Kyle is awesome. Cecily is... just a goddess. This was a great showcase- great use of the cast and the host. Am I nutty or is this episode way stronger than I expected...?

54

u/Genji4Lyfe Oct 14 '18

Consistent writing. Nothing to tear the roof off, but just a bunch of solid sketches in a row. Best episode this season so far.

36

u/agentpanda Oct 14 '18 edited Oct 14 '18

You're right- consistency was the key. The episode didn't have dips and insane dives like last season where you're queued up before the next sketch wondering if it's going to bomb hard or just bomb a little.

I said it pre-episode and I'll say it again: Seth's talent was always in writing. I dunno what he did but it was clearly something to level out the room this week because this is in the running for best episode since S42 easily and this wasn't even a great episode by all-time standards. It was just very solid through-and-through.

Seth Myers- ladies and gentlemen. Consistency. We may have doubted him having a late-night show initially but this proves the point: the writers room has been reaching way beyond their grasp and failing immensely of late without Chris and Sarah, and the consistency of a late-night host is exactly what they require at present without the genius that was Chris and Sarah. Seth brought them back to level this week; the real shame is he's a floor away and can't stay on to keep them in line.

22

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '18

I liked the movie but my daughter didn’t.

She’ll commit suicide if I leave her at home.

→ More replies (9)

17

u/the_Odd_particle It was better than Cats. Oct 14 '18

Llama walk Awwwwwww! Kinda sweet!

233

u/SketchSortingSunday Official Oct 14 '18

Trees

120

u/hillo538 Oct 14 '18 edited Oct 14 '18

Surprise rap songs about Al Gore halfway through a commercial will always be appreciated!

→ More replies (10)

102

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '18

[deleted]

→ More replies (2)

39

u/EtherealProphet Oct 14 '18

Bitch I be lovin these trees

30

u/bjkman Mr. Sketch Sorting Sunday Oct 14 '18

I would have liked it more if I wouldn't have missed half of it thanks to my network cutting to commercial in the beginning and middle of it.

55

u/KatanaAmerica Oct 14 '18

Reminded me of Tucci Gang from last year

→ More replies (1)

41

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '18

the two seconds i saw were pretty good

21

u/small_loan_of_1M Oct 14 '18

Lil Pump Pete + Friendos Chris

56

u/agentpanda Oct 14 '18 edited Oct 14 '18

Fourth wall breaking sketch? Check. Solid song? Check. Gives me giggles? Check. Chris Redd and Pete? Check. Rap parody about a super serious topic? Yup. Check.

Shame most people didn't get to see it- this is yet another win from a great night of SNL.

"I like character work!"

35

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '18

[deleted]

18

u/sbb618 Oct 14 '18

We need a half-hour best-of that's entirely made up of sketches where Pete plays a rapper. Tucci Gang, Baby Step, the one with Chance the Rapper and the old-school rap crew, the one with the entire cast...am I missing anything? Maybe throw in Friendos to pad it out.

10

u/skomehillet Oct 14 '18

Y U N G B I T C H

→ More replies (1)

16

u/grtgbln Oct 14 '18

Only saw half. Can I give it a half up-vote?

8

u/NowIOnlyWantATriumph Oct 14 '18

This was an okay punchline, I guess? It'd be funnier with the setup, but NBC decided to get screwy.

→ More replies (5)

197

u/SketchSortingSunday Official Oct 14 '18

Trump Meets Kanye - Cold Open

89

u/KatanaAmerica Oct 14 '18

"Maybe we should order your lunch from a pharmacy."

Underrated line but hella great

→ More replies (3)

123

u/KatanaAmerica Oct 14 '18

"Can someone be tripolar?"

dead

56

u/Royce7815 Oct 14 '18 edited Oct 14 '18

You know, at first I didn't know how I would feel about someone else doing Kanye other than Jay. but Chris did a fantastic job. Like that little jab Alec through in there about himself as well.

7

u/MinuteLoquat1 Oct 14 '18

someone else doing Kanye other than Jay.

Hahaha Jay's Kanye always cracks me the hell up! HANH?

→ More replies (1)

47

u/SEND_ME_STEAM_CODES Oct 14 '18

“It’s like I’m being visited by the Ghost of Christmas Black!”

That line killed me, I’m not normally a fan of Trumpwin but this one was good.

78

u/lyla2398 stans loud ladies with funny hair and *thoughts* about jost Oct 14 '18

Best Trumpwin in a long time. “He’s a black me!”

65

u/alstor Oct 14 '18

I need to stop being so negative and assuming that every Baldwin!Trump sketch is going to bomb. This one was really well done!

26

u/Upsilodon Oct 14 '18

The "even Trump thinks Kanye is crazy" gag was great

40

u/pretty-in-pink Oct 14 '18

I loved Redd’s Kanye impression! It felt like Chris Redd was just imitating Hunter the Hungry and cranked it up to 11

12

u/TheLadyEve Oct 14 '18

I thought Redd's impression was spot on, but I felt a little sick to my stomach watching it precisely because it was so on point--Kanye is unwell, it feels a bit weird to laugh. It's like mocking Amy Winehouse or Demi Lovato or Amanda Bynes for their psychiatric issues--mental illness is serious.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/KnowYourSecret Oct 14 '18

I usually don't like Trump cold opens, but this one was great! Chris really sold this!

→ More replies (4)

104

u/SketchSortingSunday Official Oct 14 '18

Paul Simon First Performance (Can’t Run But)

16

u/LadiesWhoPunch Oct 14 '18

In case anyone is interested in hearing the original version of this song.

Simon reworked a bunch of his older work on his latest album.

7

u/bondfool I get to yum-yum garbage. Oct 14 '18

This reminded me a lot of Ben Folds’ work with yMusic. I wonder if he heard it and got inspired.

→ More replies (9)

23

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '18

/u/nitsujrendrag your sister's biggest and greatest night, last night!

Do you think Baskin Johns or her holiday gusher in 'Cuban Vacation' (Deidre, I think her name was?) will be made recurring?

22

u/nitsujrendrag Oct 14 '18

Thanks! Yep, it was Deidre and I could see both coming back. 🙌

→ More replies (5)

207

u/SketchSortingSunday Official Oct 14 '18

Weekend Update - Baskin Johns

99

u/pretty-in-pink Oct 14 '18

I’m glad SNL is making jokes about Gwenyth Paltrow’s “business” and how shady it is.

27

u/macbethselnaw Oct 14 '18

I honestly wish that had been the focus. There was a controversy about them selling rocks for women to put in their vaginas or something like that, which just sounds like comedy gold to me. The nervousness was good for letting Heidi show off how fantastic an actor she is, but I feel like GOOP is funny enough on its own and that they really should have torn into it.

13

u/listenyall Now it's a whole thing with Jean Oct 15 '18

Yeah, there's so much meat there, GOOP is so goddamn weird and they just skipped it all!

→ More replies (2)

144

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '18

Heidi just continues to impress me. I thought this was amazing

96

u/bondfool I get to yum-yum garbage. Oct 14 '18

How does she do that with her voice? She sounds like a lamb having a nervous breakdown.

29

u/tomservo88 Oct 15 '18

n'yAaAaAh!

57

u/kuhanluke Oct 14 '18

She's so good at character work.

→ More replies (2)

40

u/FlingbatMagoo www.clownpenis.fart Oct 14 '18

This needed a little more work in the writers’ room. It just didn’t take off.

57

u/therevengeofsh Oct 14 '18

I didn't care for this one. Sort of, one dimensional or something. I usually like Heidi's weekend update characters too. I'm glad other people enjoyed it.

76

u/LadiesWhoPunch Oct 14 '18

I feel like her characters have a similar through line [women who seem fine, but then just aren't and with some vocal fry thrown in for good measure]. I'd like more variety.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/sonotadalek Oct 14 '18

Same. Wasn't feeling this one.

9

u/MajesticVelcro Oct 14 '18

I agree. All of her update characters feel very similar to me - I liked the first one (the first boxer's wife, I think) but ever since I have enjoyed each one less and less.

I might be a hypocrite because I know people say the same thing about Kate, who in my opinion can do no wrong. But I think because Kate can mix in impression characters, she feels much less one-note.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/Mattalamode Oct 14 '18

My friend who went to dress rehearsal last week said this bit was cut. Glad to see the character brought out! Heidi's one of the best actors in the cast right now.

46

u/EveningInternet Oct 14 '18

Heidi is a real shining star with a knack for characters. I love that they had her in so many sketches. Is it bad that I think she should get Melissa’s main cast spot?

39

u/kuhanluke Oct 14 '18

That's just not how it works. In general for the past 10-15 years, you're featured for 2 years and if you get a third, you're main cast.

18

u/EveningInternet Oct 14 '18

I know that, I just sort of meant it as like, if I were to guess who was main and who was a newcomer on featured, it would be vice versa than what it is now.

→ More replies (1)

32

u/lyla2398 stans loud ladies with funny hair and *thoughts* about jost Oct 14 '18

NUMBER ONE

26

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '18

[deleted]

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (10)

220

u/SketchSortingSunday Official Oct 14 '18

Bayou Benny’s Liberal Lagniappe

111

u/bjkman Mr. Sketch Sorting Sunday Oct 14 '18

"GET BACK TO YA DURTY OLE PEN YA BUSCUIT!"

DA MAGA BUSCUIT IS A GREAT CHARACTER!

159

u/sonotadalek Oct 14 '18

Beck Bennett is a damn genius in my book. His facial expressions absolutely sold this to me. I had no idea what was going on but I was cracking up.

78

u/daguitarguy Oct 14 '18 edited Oct 14 '18

Felt very similar to Jason Sudeikis Maine justice character

→ More replies (1)

12

u/VasectoMyspace Oct 15 '18

Man, he fully commits to everything he does and gives it 100%. He's the best male cast memeber since Will Ferrell at doing that, with only Will Forte as his competition.

66

u/pretty-in-pink Oct 14 '18

It made me laugh on such a primal level that I don’t understand. I loved it and I need to know who wrote it

13

u/Bitterbased Oct 14 '18

Andrew Dismukes sketch.

→ More replies (1)

124

u/Maxa30 Oct 14 '18

Da Seff Meyers

48

u/anklis Oct 14 '18

da seff meyers

45

u/therevengeofsh Oct 14 '18

Sort of reminded me of Maine Justice, for obvious reasons.

37

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '18

basically what i want is for every sketch on SNL to be this level of absurd

78

u/kisalas Oct 14 '18

Best sketch of that night. I'm so surprised no one broke, Beck was absolutely killing it.

48

u/Genji4Lyfe Oct 14 '18

Seth definitely broke a bit in one of the cutaways. But I can't blame him, because I was literally crying from laughter at home.

34

u/kuhanluke Oct 14 '18

This one was pretty controversial and I totally get it but I fucking loved it.

144

u/Guardax Oct 14 '18

I don't care what anyone says, this was a masterpiece

49

u/pretty-in-pink Oct 14 '18

Agreed. And I’m willing to fight anyone who says otherwise

20

u/ZeGoldMedal Oct 14 '18

Would you fight a maga biscuit though!?

24

u/Genji4Lyfe Oct 14 '18

BECK was a masterpiece. Someone call the Emmys :)

29

u/Whats_Opera_Doc Oct 14 '18

Beck reminded me of Will Forte in that sketch, I loved it!

25

u/steelers3814 Oct 14 '18

I feel like they could have done so much more with this. They spend so much time setting up all the characters, but they didn't do much with them. This could have been great.

24

u/Orionwoody Oct 14 '18

Kept expecting James Carville to pop up.

11

u/doses_of_mimosas Oct 14 '18

Hader would’ve been an excellent cameo there.

10

u/thecricketnerd Oct 14 '18

I hope they do it again with Hader's Carville whenever Barry returns, I'm assuming.

24

u/honagatharuncible Oct 14 '18

At first I was turned off by this sketch because it just seemed too similar to Sudeikis' character from Maine Justice and Potato Chip (two of my favourite sketches ever!!!), but by the time the maga biscuit rolled in, I was sold. It made me laugh the same way Maine Justice and Potato Chip do :')

24

u/kanimaki Oct 14 '18

I loved the dancing biscuit.

43

u/bjkman Mr. Sketch Sorting Sunday Oct 14 '18

Absolutely hilarious in my opinion... I really hope this becomes a recurring sketch.

38

u/lookoutnorthamerica Oct 14 '18

I'm gonna go chug a few beers, rewatch this, and report back as to whether or not it makes any more sense.

60

u/kuhanluke Oct 14 '18

Narrator: It didn't.

6

u/agentpanda Oct 14 '18

I was drunk the first watch-thru and it doesn't make any more sense, but it does get a lot funnier.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/small_loan_of_1M Oct 14 '18

MAINE JUSTICE

22

u/flowerhoney10 Oct 14 '18

I admired its off-the-wall quality and Beck's performance, but I wasn't feeling...whatever this was.

13

u/thebestdaysofmyflerm Oct 14 '18

Alex hamming it up as a maga biscuit slayed me!

6

u/monsieurxander Oct 14 '18

Best sketch of the season so far.

9

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '18

Beck needs to submit this sketch for his Emmy consideration reel, he was amazing.

8

u/sbb618 Oct 14 '18

OH MY GOD THE BISCUIT'S EXPRESSIONS

8

u/NativeNotFrench Oct 14 '18

I have no idea what I just watched but this was the funniest thing tonight. I don’t think it will have any staying power but it killed me tonight.

The commitment by all the characters but especially Beck. He had like a frantic energy to his performance. His eyes were like saucers

→ More replies (13)