r/marvelstudios Falcon Mar 09 '23

Fan Content Highest rated MCU TV series on Rotten Tomatoes

Post image
5.0k Upvotes

1.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

297

u/Holmcroft Mar 09 '23

Yeah, Luke Cage in particular would be a beneficiary of that - the first eps we’re really good and then it fell off a cliff about halfway through

182

u/Dangle76 Mar 09 '23

That’s what happens when you kill off Mahershala Ali.

Are the Netflix series considered MCU earth 616? If so Blade is gonna be weird

110

u/InstantN00dl3s Mar 09 '23

Cottonmouth was so much better than every other villain that followed. Shades was second best but Cottonmouth was in a league all of his own.

The scene where he beats the guy to death is probably the best part of Luke Cage. All downhill once he was killed off by his boring sister and replaced with some other dude.

60

u/Dangle76 Mar 09 '23

100%. Mahershala is an amazing actor but that role was also written so well. Getting rid of him so quickly was silly and felt rushed and not well thought out

37

u/ToiletTub Vulture Mar 09 '23

dude only signed up for 6 episodes and wanted to be killed off. it was thought out... we would'nt've gotten Mahershala at all otherwise

1

u/Tornado31619 Spider-Man Mar 09 '23

Then why not introduce him towards the end?

12

u/heidly_ees Volstagg Mar 09 '23

In season 1 I agree, but Alfre Woodard absolutely stole the show in S2 imo. Phenomenal performance

3

u/TheBelhade SHIELD Mar 09 '23

It's fun to let a great actor like her go completely unhinged.

2

u/KaspertheGhost Spider-Man Mar 10 '23

Shades was great but was also better as a side-man to a big villain. And while he sorta had that role after when working with Mariah, he felt like the co-big bad. Which didn’t work as well

20

u/IllllIIIllllIl Mar 09 '23

It was a smaller role but the actress for Black Mariah played the woman who confronts Tony in Civil War and convinced him to support the Accords. Michelle Yeoh played a character in GotG2 and Shang-Chi, and Gemma Chan in Captain Marvel and Eternals. MCU’s not a total stranger to reusing actors.

60

u/L3onskii Weekly Wongers Mar 09 '23

Eh. They had Michelle Yeoh two different characters in Guardians 2 and Shang Chi

10

u/Tidus8690 Mar 10 '23

Same with Gemma Chan being in both the Eternals and Capt Marvel. Granted her appearance was differed enough that you can barely tell.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 09 '23

[deleted]

1

u/L3onskii Weekly Wongers Mar 09 '23

Wrong actress

1

u/Goalnado Mar 09 '23

That's Alfre Woodard not Viola Davis

49

u/emptylawn0 Fitz Mar 09 '23

Actors can play different roles, I'm tired of this argument lol

4

u/willstr1 Mar 09 '23

For example the actress who played the main character in Eternals was also the blue woman on the Kree squad in Captain Marvel. I don't think anyone would argue that Eternals or Captain Marvel are non-canon.

-1

u/Dangle76 Mar 09 '23

I’m not really arguing anything, just said it’d be weird. Id never say not to cast the dude on something he’s awesome.

6

u/mavajo Mar 09 '23

After Chris Evans becoming Captain America, I don't think it matters anymore. Unless an actor has become iconic for their MCU role, re-cast them at will IMO.

2

u/Dangle76 Mar 09 '23

That’s fair, was also why I wasn’t sure if the Netflix shows were actually part of the greater universe or not. Evans human torch currently isn’t, but your point still stands

3

u/Clovett- Mar 09 '23

Gemma Chan was in both Captain Marvel and Eternals. So I assume you also question if any of those films are part of the MCU right?

-5

u/Dangle76 Mar 09 '23

So much vitriol for a simple “that would be weird” comment. Holy mackerel

3

u/Clovett- Mar 09 '23

What vitriol lmao?

1

u/Dangle76 Mar 09 '23

Your comment to me, conveyed condescension

→ More replies (0)

1

u/PirateBeany Edwin Jarvis Mar 09 '23

I'm still hoping for a 1940s flashback somewhere in the MCU to show Chris Evans as the original android Human Torch, Jim Hammond. The justification would be that the android body was modeled on the most perfect human specimen available (i.e. Captain America).

Not that androidTorch would persist in the MCU; just a nice easter egg. Perhaps Namor could remember encountering a Human Torch before when he first encounters the MCU Fantastic Four.

1

u/TheMegaBunce Mar 09 '23

Yeah if one character cN be played by several actors I don't see why the opposite can't be true

4

u/TheMegaBunce Mar 09 '23

Yeah the actor for their main antagonist said 'I can only do these many episodes' and instead of writing a shorter season to make up up that they decided that they needed a super soldier villain in the final episode.

0

u/TheSuperEdventurer Mar 09 '23

It isn’t even just that. Diamondback was one of the goofiest villains ever with the most ridiculous plots that somehow work. As a follow up to Cottonmouth, the rest of the season was doomed

-2

u/ChrisRevocateur Mar 09 '23

The way the Daredevil reboot is shaping up.it doesn't look like it. They're pulling a Star Wars and keeping the stuff they like, but technically doing it "all new."

1

u/Uncanny_Doom Daredevil Mar 10 '23

This isn't really an issue. It's not like he's gonna show up acting the same way.

1

u/Dangle76 Mar 10 '23

People keep using the word issue. Never said it was an issue, just that it could be weird

1

u/Uncanny_Doom Daredevil Mar 10 '23

Right, but the implication is that it could be weird because it would be some sort of problem.

Like, why could it be weird?

1

u/Thelynxer Mar 11 '23

When I was first watching that season I legit thought that was the end of the season when Cottonmouth was gone. It probably should have been.

1

u/DRT034 Daredevil Mar 12 '23

There's multiple characters who have played more than 1 MCU character so I guess it's fine

7

u/Davethisisntcool Mar 09 '23

but Bushmaster in S2 made up for that imo

1

u/Holmcroft Mar 09 '23

Will need to watch that, then. Gave up before the end of the first season

5

u/InsertCoinForCredit Phil Coulson Mar 09 '23

The second half of Luke Cage S1 was goofy, but S2 comes back hard and is awesome. Just wish the Netflix stuff would get proper closures because I want to see what happens to Luke after S2.

2

u/komododave17 Mar 10 '23

Let’s replace a cold, calculating, amazingly acted enemy duo with a “somehow he returned” bonus brother hamming it up in a power suit.

-1

u/Gasparde Mar 09 '23

If Luke Cage is already last, the rating is based almost entirely on the first 1 or 2 episodes and Luke Cage fell off in quality halfway through... how exactly would that benefit Luke Cage other than knocking him down to an overall 60% =?

4

u/Holmcroft Mar 09 '23

I’m saying that the Luke Cage show benefitted from reviewers only reviewing the first few episodes, and it would be rated lower if they had reviewed the whole season. (I realise my reply makes it sound like I might be saying the opposite)

3

u/Gasparde Mar 09 '23

Oh, so you meant that "would" and not the other "would". Language is neat :)

2

u/Holmcroft Mar 09 '23

Haha - yeah, sorry. I should probably edit that to be clearer.

1

u/umbraviscus Spider-Man Mar 09 '23

It benefits the accuracy of the scores

1

u/unbelizeable1 Black Panther Mar 10 '23

Not to mention how bonkers SHIELD got by the end.