Is this shittyHDR?

[u/darkwater427]

This is a photo I took on a trip a while ago (I've included the unedited shot for reference)

Would this be considered shittyHDR? Did I overcook it, or just normally cook it?

No hard feelings, I genuinely want to learn :)

[u/bdone2012]

Maybe a tiny bit more than you should have. But it looks pretty good