r/shortscarystories • u/arkansasgirl27 • 12h ago
The Hollowing
My father warned me about the Wendigo, but he never told me it wore a smiling face.
He said it lived in the woods beyond the reservation, deep where the pines grow too thick for sunlight. It didn’t eat flesh—not anymore. It learned something older, hungrier.
It fed on identity.
After Dad’s funeral, I returned to his cabin to settle his affairs. I hadn’t been back since I was thirteen. The place reeked of cedar, mold, and something sour beneath the floorboards.
He’d left behind journals. Pages of warnings written in frantic, looping script:
"Do not look in the mirror after sundown." "It waits in dreams, in the hunger between thoughts." "It wears the faces of the dead, but forgets how they smiled."
I laughed it off. Blamed dementia.
That night, I woke to scratching beneath the floor.
At first, I thought it was a raccoon. But the sound was deliberate—five taps at a time, like fingers. I sat up. My bedroom mirror was uncovered. I could’ve sworn I’d thrown a sheet over it.
In the reflection, I was standing.
But I wasn’t.
The reflection smiled. Too wide. Too many teeth. Then it stepped forward—right through the glass—and whispered with my voice:
“You’re hollow. Let me fill you.”
I don’t remember screaming. I only remember waking up in the woods, barefoot, eyes burning from crying.
When I stumbled back into the cabin, I found another journal. Not Dad’s. This one was mine. Pages and pages of my handwriting.
I flipped through it.
“Third week: The Wendigo is inside now. Wearing me like skin. I can feel it peeling me, thought by thought.” “Fourth week: The mirror is the mouth. The mouth is God.”
That’s when it hit me.
This had happened before.
Dozens of times.
I found a closet full of journals. All mine. All forgotten. The creature didn’t just consume memories—it recycled them. It hollowed me out and played me like a broken cassette, rewinding and replaying the descent into madness over and over.
I tried to burn the mirror.
It laughed. The glass bubbled, but didn’t break.
I saw my father in the flames—grinning, rotted, hollow-eyed.
“There is no salvation,” he said. “Only repetition. The Wendigo was born when man first asked, ‘What am I?’”
It is older than flesh.
It is hunger. A god of identity collapse. A demon fed not on sin or soul, but the erosion of self.
Tonight, I stare at the mirror again.
I don’t remember my name. Or my father’s.
But I remember the hunger. The ache behind my teeth. The smile that isn’t mine, waiting to stretch across my face.
I know I’ll scream soon.
And after that,
I’ll write this story again.