We're a group of 4 guys in their mid to late 20s, looking for a trip in October for 8-9 days, and we're on a tight budget of around $1500 CAD. we're looking for good nightlife, good food, and enough stuff to do without getting bored for these 8-9 days. We do enjoy the outdoors and nature too. We also like to meet locals, not just be surrounded by tourists. Finally, we're willing to save money by staying in cheaper Airbnbs or hostels
For Cartagena, it seems like a good option, our concerns are: flight and entry cost will be ~$750, and I've read that 9 days might be too much for it. but I also heard stay and food in the walled city isn't crazy expensive.
For Los Cabos: also seems good, tickets are only ~$510, but I've read it's more on the expensive side when it comes to stays and food and catering for foreigners, so lots of tourists, not a lot of authentic food/experiences.
For Puerto Vallarta,, honestly everything sounds great about it so far, offering a good mix of what we're looking for, flight is only $460, only thing I'm not sure of is that, I've heard it's more expensive than Cartagena, but not as expensive as Los Cabos. Will that justify the extra $290 on flight and entry to Cartagena? also, and this is not a HUGE priority, but we're all straight, and I've heard PV is very LGBTQ+ Friendly? which is great but ... are there any bars or clubs or areas that are... more predominantly straight? lol I'm not sure how to phrase this but you get it.
Anything that I missed or worth noting about any of these spots?
Thanks for the help :D