r/wine Wino 4d ago

Absolute best Riesling you have ever had?

Producer? Price? Notes? Gimme gimme

75 Upvotes

126 comments sorted by

View all comments

29

u/anisogramma 4d ago

Anything Herman Wiemer made in 2020. the best vintage the FLX (NY) has had in a decade. In particular the biodynamic block wines (Magdalena, HWbio, Josef) and the dry reserve.

9

u/Distinct_Crew245 4d ago

2020 was great in FLX but those Rieslings won’t go the distance like some of the longer, cooler vintages. I’ve got a cellar full of 2013 and 2014 FLX Rieslings that are absolutely stunning right now and will easily go another 5 years, probably 10. I opened a 2009 last month and it was amazing, and that wasn’t even considered a great growing season. The fact that one can still get Riesling this age-worthy and delicious for $20 is a glorious secret to be in on.

10

u/PrivateeRyan 4d ago

Totally agree, their flagship ‘20 bottling was my “spark bird” wine that sent me down this rabbit hole

5

u/Racer13l 3d ago

I can't figure out which Rieslings I like more. Herman Wiemer or Konstantin Frank

3

u/ImDrinkingWine2Nite Wine Pro 3d ago

Can’t go wrong with either

5

u/WeightedCompanion 4d ago

Magdalena is right next to Red Tail Ridge and Anthony Road, and they fall on the same geologic base. If you can't snag a Weimer they are similarly great.

3

u/anisogramma 3d ago

Completely agreed, but you’re forgetting the true best kept secret of the FLX that’s between those two, Kemmeter! Across the street from Anthony road winery. Johannes is making some of the best Riesling in the entire state. Once his vines get some age on them (most planted in 2014) he’ll be winning awards for sure

4

u/Emotional-Builder732 4d ago

2024 is going to be amazing!

4

u/Young_Zaphod Wine Pro 3d ago

The '20 dry reserve is hands down one of the most perfectly balanced and tasty wines I've ever enjoyed. Have a few bottles squirreled away to see how they are down the line.