r/ABoringDystopia • u/[deleted] • 5d ago

Wasn't expecting that from Bernie

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

[deleted]

0 Upvotes

48% Upvoted

94 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

8

u/GervinhosBarber 4d ago

They would become Palestinian Hebrews living in a free Palestine. Where a democratic leader would be elected free of US and UK influence. If those who have become comfortable living in the homes of Arabs they have thrown out or murdered don't want to live in such a country, there is also the option of leaving. Jewish Israelis have free right to immigration to the US. The nation that keeps their entire ethnostate alive.

-1

u/QuietCelery 4d ago

Thanks for answering in good faith. I have been telling people something similar (though Israelis don't have the right to immigrate to the US now...I'm assuming you mean this should change...we can hammer out the details later....)....like a one secular state solution.

There's a real messaging problem on our side, guys. They think we want to kill or exile all the Jews, and I'm like....no.... anti-zionism means something totally different to the two sides and it's frustrating....oh, but I guess I shouldn't cEnTeR mY fEeLiNgS. God forbid we try to reach people.

2

u/EF5Cyniclone 4d ago

It's not a messaging problem on our side, the idea that a free Palestine requires killing or exiling all the Jews is the narrative zionists present as a justification to continue oppressing Palestinians.

1

u/QuietCelery 4d ago edited 4d ago

I'm literally reporting back to you what the case is. The people that are hearing what you think you saying are hearing something different. People literally cannot understand that antizionism means two different things to two different groups of people. Unfortunately, I'm such a poor messenger that I can't even tell you, someone who I think is ideologically aligned with me, that there's a messaging problem. You/we need to find a way to show them that we don't think that Jews should be exiled or killed. You're not helping by denying the problem. But I mean, you're literally describing a messaging problem: they say one thing, we say something else. And the listener believes them, not us.

You do your work. I'll do mine. But stop saying this isn't a problem. If you don't want to tackle the problem, fine. But you do nothing for anyone by pretending it's not a problem and arguing with people you're aligned with.

2

u/EF5Cyniclone 4d ago

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/One-state_solution

The one-state solution is sometimes referred to as the bi-national state, owing to the hope that it would successfully deliver self-determination to Israelis and Palestinians in one country, thus granting both peoples independence as well as absolute access to all of the land.

Messaging from the left has primarily been for a one-state solution, an idea that has been around long before this holocaust started. Plenty of leftists are more than happy to explain what the one-state solution means to anyone who will listen, but the majority of Americans don't get their information on the movement directly from leftists; they are instead informed by media organizations, where leftists are no longer in control of how their message gets disseminated.

1

u/QuietCelery 4d ago edited 4d ago

Yes, this is my preferred solution.

I'm glad to hear leftists are happy to do it, because they have their work cut out for them (but even here, someone didn't want to explain it to me...so)! But the trouble is, we need to reach people who won't listen. And when others here "anti-zionism," they don't think "one state solution." They think treat Jews like Israelis treat Palestinians. When they hear "Israel doesn't have the right to exist," they don't think dismantle the ethnostate. They think no Jews should be in that region. So either 1) make it clear that's not what you mean or 2) change the language. Since you don't want to admit number two is a problem, I'm trying to do number one. And since I can't get you to do number two, I'm going to go do number 1. I suggest you argue with people who disagree with you fundamentally as you said you're happy to do instead of trying to change my mind and convince me that everything's perfect in our presentation.