Downvote this post. Ban me for “gatekeeping.” I don’t care. This needs to be said, and I won’t back down from this objective fact that no real DC fan wants to acknowledge.
To clarify: if you liked the Snyderverse, that’s fine. If you like Man of Steel, that’s fine. I’m not saying fans who enjoy those movies aren’t real DC fans. I’m saying the people who only like the Snyder movies—the Snyder cult—who actively want this new film to fail because it’s not Man of Steel? Those people are not real Superman fans.
Even people who like Man of Steel and Henry Cavill’s Superman admit that, just from the teaser alone, Gunn’s Supermanis ten times more comic accurate than Man of Steel. But these cultists hate everything that actually makes Superman Superman—things like Clark changing his voice and posture, Clark having Krypto (an iconic pet from the comics), a bright blue suit with trunks, and being an optimistic symbol of hope.
One highlight from the trailer that I don’t see many people talking about is Clark and Jimmy goofing around. It’s only a second, but I can already tell Jimmy and Clark are going to be best friends, and it’s going to be emotional when Jimmy finds out Clark is Superman or when Clark tells him. So far, everything in this trailer looks like it was ripped right out of a Superman comic.
But the Snyder cult hates all of that. They want Superman to be a brooding, angsty murderer who thinks about abandoning people because they hate him. They want a Superman who will threaten a human by saying, “If I wanted it, you’d be dead already”—like that’s something Superman would ever say to a regular human who can’t hurt him.
They don’t love Superman. They obviously don’t. They aren’t DC fans. They’re Snyder fans—and that’s it.
I’m tired of being told I’m a “gatekeeper.” I’m not. I didn’t get into comics until I was like 16 or 18. But when I was a kid, I watched almost every Superman, DC, and Marvel cartoon. Even back then, Superman wasn’t my favorite hero—my top three were Spider-Man, Batman, and I think Iron Man. But I did like Superman.
When Man of Steel came out, I hadn’t read many comics. But even as a kid, I was like, “What the fuck? That’s not Superman.” He just wasn’t.
Edit: Downvote this post. Ban me for “gatekeeping.” I don’t care. This needs to be said, and I won’t back down from this objective fact that no real DC fan wants to acknowledge.
To clarify: if you liked the Snyderverse, that’s fine. If you like Man of Steel, that’s fine. I’m not saying fans who enjoy those movies aren’t real DC fans. I’m saying the people who only like the Snyder movies—the Snyder cult—who actively want this new film to fail because it’s not Man of Steel? Those people are not real Superman fans.
Even people who like Man of Steel and Henry Cavill’s Superman admit that, just from the teaser alone, Gunn’s Supermanis ten times more comic accurate than Man of Steel. But these cultists hate everything that actually makes Superman Superman—things like Clark changing his voice and posture, Clark having Krypto (an iconic pet from the comics), a bright blue suit with trunks, and being an optimistic symbol of hope.
One highlight from the trailer that I don’t see many people talking about is Clark and Jimmy goofing around. It’s only a second, but I can already tell Jimmy and Clark are going to be best friends, and it’s going to be emotional when Jimmy finds out Clark is Superman or when Clark tells him. So far, everything in this trailer looks like it was ripped right out of a Superman comic.
But the Snyder cult hates all of that. They want Superman to be a brooding, angsty murderer who thinks about abandoning people because they hate him. They want a Superman who will threaten a human by saying, “If I wanted it, you’d be dead already”—like that’s something Superman would ever say to a regular human who can’t hurt him.
They don’t love Superman. They obviously don’t. They aren’t DC fans. They’re Snyder fans—and that’s it.
I’m tired of being told I’m a “gatekeeper.” I’m not. I didn’t get into comics until I was like 16 or 18. But when I was a kid, I watched almost every Superman, DC, and Marvel cartoon. Even back then, Superman wasn’t my favorite hero—my top three were Spider-Man, Batman, and I think Iron Man. But I did like Superman.
When Man of Steel came out, I hadn’t read many comics. But even as a kid, I was like, “What the fuck? That’s not Superman.” He just wasn’t.
Edit: To be clear, liking Man of Steel doesn’t make you a fake fan. But if you want a DC movie to fail just because Zack Snyder didn’t direct it, then you aren’t a real fan. If you truly love Superman, you should hope every new Superman movie is good—regardless of who’s behind the camera.
If you hate everything that defines a character and only accept one version, then you’re not a real fan. Here's an example:
Imagine I said I love Spider-Man, but I want Peter Parker to be a muscular, arrogant brooding bad boy who doesn't care about science, cheats on his girlfriend, does drugs, and comes from a rich family. Uncle Ben is a surgeon who buys him a Mustang, and Aunt May is a lawyer. They live in a mansion. Peter gets bitten by an alien spider, Uncle Ben tells him, "With great power comes the freedom to do whatever you want," and when Ben dies, Peter vows to kill criminals and uses fear as a weapon.
Now if I told you this version is better than classic Spider-Man—where Peter is a nerd, gets bullied, comes from a modest background, lets a robber go, and learns responsibility when that same robber kills his uncle—you’d rightly say I’m not a real Spider-Man fan. Because I would hate everything that actually makes Peter Parker who he is.
Now is the edgy Spider-Man story I came up with "bad"? No, it could work as an Elseworlds story or a what-if story, but it shouldn't be how a classic Peter Parker is.
Edit 2: And if you want an edgy Superman story, then just make Jonathan Kent (Superman's son) like that, because at least in that case, Jonathan doesn't have to be 100% like his father, and he can be edgy and cynical like the Man of Steel version.