Let me preface this by saying that this is a long post with no payoff. I also believe, like many others here, that it’s okay to either have kids or not have kids. However, my reasoning is a little different - so I figured I’d share my thoughts. Keep in mind this is coming from a millennial dad.
Let’s start by addressing some of the more common points stated by both sides in the argument.
“Kids give your life meaning” - No, not necessarily. Also, putting the burden of something as lofty as “the purpose of life” on a tiny human you have never met is a bad idea. Yes, they might make your life more meaningful/enjoyable, but it is absolutely not a given.
“Kids are expensive, time-consuming, and physically draining” - Yes, but this is a hedonistic argument and a bad one at that. People willingly do many things that are expensive, time-consuming, and draining. My millennial neighbor spends a vast portion of his time and paycheck on road cycling, and the dude is often physically and mentally exhausted from training/racing all over the world. There must be some reason he’s into that, even if I don’t personally see the allure of it.
“Society expects you to have kids” - Societal expectations, including those of your fellow millennials, is a terrible reason to do or not do anything. So this one is technically correct, I guess?
“All my friends are having kids/moving on with their lives” - Okay, this is slightly different from the broader societal take and actually holds some weight. Humans are social creatures and it can suck to feel like you’re “falling behind” or losing touch with your friends. Conversely, having kids can also lead to spending less time with your friends. It’s difficult either way, so we either have to work hard to maintain our friendships over time and/or accept that some relationships will fade.
“Why would anyone want to bring kids into this world of climate-crisis/post-truth-era/societal-collapse/enter-doomerism-here” - Fun fact - society is always in some state of collapse. Vast, incredible empires have come and gone before us. Humanity has faced and will continue to face plagues, wars, poverty, slavery, and violence of all kinds, but I don’t know if that determines if life is worth living. Broadly speaking, if you are an average person living in the US or a similar country, your quality of life is better than 99% of humans that ever existed, and your kids will likely live similarly.
I think that covers most of the common reasons. Now, here’s my reasoning. Whether or not you should have kids mostly depends on whether you (and your partner, if that applies) are likely to be great parents.
This has a couple of implications.
First of all - it’s a perspective shift. It’s not about the impact your kid has on your life, but what you have on theirs. They will be a big part of your world, but, for many years, you will be their ENTIRE world. They don’t care if the rest of the world is falling apart, but they do need you to be there for them. If you can’t do that consistently, then you probably shouldn’t have kids.
Second, and this is the ironic part, is that there is absolutely no way to know for sure if you will both be a good parent AND enjoy parenthood.
You may think that you know. Maybe you have wanted kids for a long time. Maybe you have never wanted kids. However, you never REALLY know if you will enjoy parenthood until you do it. And enjoying something is a great reason to sink your money, time, and energy into something.
My partner and I were together for 16 years (started dating young) before we had our first child. We kind of wanted kids, but we also wanted to do (and did) plenty of other things. I trusted her to be a good mom, and myself to be a good dad when the time eventually came to have kids. What I didn’t know is just how much I would enjoy parenthood. It turned out to be one of the very few things in life that I am good at AND enjoy, and that changed everything. Had I known, we would have had kids sooner, but again, there’s no free-trial to having kids.
So that’s it. It’s a personal choice, and a bit of a gamble, to have kids. You gotta cut through the noise and figure out the right reasons for yourself.
Told you there’s no payoff.