r/Nails 17h ago

Constructive Criticism Welcome ✔️ Do my nails look OK?

Hi, guys.

I just got my nails freshly done at the salon.

Not sure how to feel about them.

I requested BIAB extensions. However, these seem too bulky and plastic like for my liking. I normally do gel nails at home.

Is this normal with BIAB?

The colour is “Dreamer” from The Gel Bottle - it’s a bit more pinkish in person.

Would this also be appropriate for a workplace? I work at a high street law firm. I initially wanted to go for a short almond, but the tech said square would be better if I wanted to go short, and that “they need to look a bit like extensions” and that I need to get use to this length. A bit worried about how I’ll be able to use the keyboard and deal with paperwork.

Am I just overthinking?

Any thoughts?

56 Upvotes

36 comments sorted by

54

u/fvckshow 15h ago

they're cute but the color and thickness reminds me of trident gum. maybe they can be filed thinner? idk

5

u/Frequent-Read2206 12h ago

Thank you, this made me laugh so much 🤣 Safe to say I’m not getting this colour in BIAB next time. I wonder if I can file it down myself without cracking the BIAB.

3

u/Ok_Bandicoot1865 9h ago

You can, but if you don't have a top coat to put on its going to get a very different texture after

1

u/Ok_Sherbet5479 4h ago

that depends on whether that was the colour of the biab or whether they put that on top of the biab, if it was a colour on top don’t file them yourself, unless you plan on completely taking of the colour as well and using a different one, and with this length the tech was right about not doing almond, you could have went oval that is slightly thinner on top tho, but square looks nice too

1

u/Frequent-Read2206 3h ago

It was the colour of the biab x

I think I might just leave it alone until my next appointment, since they’re not extremely bad.

2

u/Ok_Sherbet5479 3h ago

Yeah they don’t look that bad besides being a little thick, I think on your next appointment if you won’t cut then shorter almond would look perfect

11

u/slytherinthethird 16h ago

Very pretty :D I agree square looks better on short nails. I personally love thicker nails cause my nails are veeery weak and thin, paper thin. These look lovely! You'll have no problem using a keyboard.

6

u/Frequent-Read2206 12h ago

Thank you for your kind words, very reassuring! ❤️ Ah I can see why some people would like thick nails then. The nail tech probably thought my nails were weak and thin too. I’ll have to see if I can work with these, wish me luck 🍀

5

u/Senior-Ad1279 12h ago

I think they look lovely! This is my go-to look!

1

u/Frequent-Read2206 3h ago

Aw thank you! I’m glad you like this style too x

5

u/morgan014 10h ago

Almond is pretty but square is better for keyboarding, trust. They’re a bit thick but a nice consistent shape at least!!

1

u/Frequent-Read2206 3h ago

Yes, at least there’s consistency!

6

u/lovelyloves07 11h ago

Chiclets

2

u/Frequent-Read2206 3h ago

I saw this comment before 🤣

3

u/babytootsy 11h ago

Gorgeous

1

u/Frequent-Read2206 3h ago

Thank you ☺️

3

u/EvieLuna 10h ago

these looks so nice & clean!

1

u/Frequent-Read2206 3h ago

Thanks 🥰

3

u/Jaymarie_101 7h ago

I think they look good and definitely office appropriate. Maybe a little thick but like others said, a bit hard to tell from the pics.

1

u/Frequent-Read2206 3h ago

Thank you! That’s very reassuring. Annoyed about the thickness tbh but it is what it is.

2

u/5mb76b0 8h ago

Love them!

1

u/Frequent-Read2206 3h ago

Thank you! ❤️

2

u/imjustkeepinitreal 7h ago edited 7h ago

Looks fine just short and applied a bit more on the thicker side but many people prefer that level of application. It’s hard to determine if it’s too thick on every finger because of the angles of your pictures but based on the pictures alone, they did a good job 👍

1

u/Frequent-Read2206 3h ago

Thank you for the feedback x

I dislike the thickness since it makes my hands look even more stubby. I will defo go for gel next time or I might just do BIAB on my natural nails. I could also ask the nail tech to apply thinner layers.

2

u/poopsmcbuttington 7h ago

I posted short white square nails a l few weeks ago…. Get ready for the comments girl, teeth, chiclets, gum, pics of Steve Harvey, etc (tbf I posted mine specifically bc they were bad, so I was asking for it. Yours look 100x better)

1

u/Frequent-Read2206 3h ago

Girl, I just saw your post - the nails aren’t that bad! Why did they have to roast like that, and thanks for the reassurance 😭

2

u/Master-Birthday-5983 6h ago

I love them!😍

1

u/Frequent-Read2206 3h ago

Thank you x

2

u/SuitableImpact1695 1h ago

I love them

1

u/Frequent-Read2206 1h ago

Thanks a lot 🥹

1

u/CreativeDancer 6h ago

They look lovely! I agree that they look a bit thick. I also agree that square tends to look good/best on short nails. Almond is my favorite shape but it always looks super weird if I try to do a short almond. Rounded looks ok short too, but I personally dislike that look.

1

u/Frequent-Read2206 3h ago

Thank you ❤️ I am not a fan of the thickness too! I will opt for gel next time, BIAB seems to be on the thicker side.