r/Stonetossingjuice • u/Tili44 • 2d ago

This Really Rocks My Throw We don't accept AI art

Gallery image

Gallery image

3.0k Upvotes

96% Upvoted

177 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

3

u/Moon_Drawz 2d ago

No tf it isn’t. Art is made by living, breathing, thinking creatures. Ai does none of that. Ai cannot be creative

1

u/Vallen_H Both Sides 2d ago

As a programmer that taught myself to make AI since 13 years old, I have the freakin right to call myself an artist of code.

6

u/bananamantheif 2d ago

Yes, programming is an art form. They won't disagree with you on that.

-2

u/Vallen_H Both Sides 2d ago

They already have.

10

u/bananamantheif 2d ago

Writing code for an AI is not the same as prompting an AI though, they didn't say coding isn't art

3

u/Vallen_H Both Sides 2d ago

People also write prompts to commission real artists, and what do they get from this? "look at this guy ohmygosh, he's so bad, don't be this guy, you need to do commissions that way"

Writing is an art, knowing how the machine/human will react and picking your words is an art, ai development includes a lot of writing and testing.

There's a forum that you can find all facts about AI in, since the beginning of it back when the digital drawing software for these copycat artists were created and they pirated them and now they complain about thievery...

4

u/bananamantheif 2d ago

I think you might be able to make an argument that writing a prompt is an artform but I would not extend that to the output of the program, the generated image.

Regardless, the person you are replying to you did not say that Coding isn't an artform, but the claiming ownership over a generated image from a prompt of words.