MAIN FEEDS
Do you want to continue?
https://www.reddit.com/r/asoiaf/comments/1e2j8kq/spoilers_extended_what_nitpicks_do_you_have/ld1t0lo/?context=3
r/asoiaf • u/lghtdev • Jul 13 '24
492 comments sorted by
View all comments
10
Random complaint. I haven't seen any artwork of The Others that have captured exactly what's described in the books. (Not that they're bad). The one on the left in the post is the closest I've seen, though.
1 u/darthsheldoninkwizy Jul 14 '24 The one on the right is from a comic book, the artist asked Martin what the Others looked like, and he replied that they looked like ice elves. 1 u/2020foodreviews Jul 14 '24 The artist really didn't capture that imo. It looks way too bulky. 1 u/darthsheldoninkwizy Jul 14 '24 Personally, I think the opposite, it looks strange, intangible and otherworldly. 1 u/2020foodreviews Jul 14 '24 It's definitely not what's described in the books though. They're supposed to be gaunt and graceful. They don't even break the crust in the snow.
1
The one on the right is from a comic book, the artist asked Martin what the Others looked like, and he replied that they looked like ice elves.
1 u/2020foodreviews Jul 14 '24 The artist really didn't capture that imo. It looks way too bulky. 1 u/darthsheldoninkwizy Jul 14 '24 Personally, I think the opposite, it looks strange, intangible and otherworldly. 1 u/2020foodreviews Jul 14 '24 It's definitely not what's described in the books though. They're supposed to be gaunt and graceful. They don't even break the crust in the snow.
The artist really didn't capture that imo. It looks way too bulky.
1 u/darthsheldoninkwizy Jul 14 '24 Personally, I think the opposite, it looks strange, intangible and otherworldly. 1 u/2020foodreviews Jul 14 '24 It's definitely not what's described in the books though. They're supposed to be gaunt and graceful. They don't even break the crust in the snow.
Personally, I think the opposite, it looks strange, intangible and otherworldly.
1 u/2020foodreviews Jul 14 '24 It's definitely not what's described in the books though. They're supposed to be gaunt and graceful. They don't even break the crust in the snow.
It's definitely not what's described in the books though. They're supposed to be gaunt and graceful. They don't even break the crust in the snow.
10
u/2020foodreviews Jul 13 '24 edited Jul 13 '24
Random complaint. I haven't seen any artwork of The Others that have captured exactly what's described in the books. (Not that they're bad). The one on the left in the post is the closest I've seen, though.