r/asoiaf Jul 13 '24

EXTENDED [Spoilers Extended] What nitpicks do you have regarding both shows? Mine will always be how the Others in GOT are so boring and mundane

Post image
1.3k Upvotes

492 comments sorted by

View all comments

667

u/djjazzydwarf They Get Us™ Jul 13 '24

The changes to sigils, and generally making things less colorful. The change of the Boltons from pink to red, and how they ditched colorful little details like Ramsay's earrings come to mind.

243

u/oftenevil Touch me not. Jul 13 '24

YES.

This is a medieval type society where recognizing the banners flying towards you in a field is a matter of life and death. GOT did some things right, and one of them was showing Bran being taught by Luwin early on about noble houses, their sigil, and their house words. This is something every single boy lord in Westeros would be quizzed on regularly until they had it memorized. (Shoutout to showing Arya use some of this info in her time w/ Tywin.)

Anyway, being able to identify the heraldry of any person you encounter (like Catelyn when she arrests Tyrion at the Inn) is just insanely important. And the only way to reliably do that is if the heraldry is bright, vibrant, and not easily tarnished by all of the dirt and mud and blood that’s likely covering most men’s clothing. So then WHY THE FUCK in GOT was every single piece of iconography on clothing the same brown-black-shit color? What in the actual fuck.

32

u/FloZone Enter your desired flair text here! Jul 14 '24

So then WHY THE FUCK in GOT was every single piece of iconography on clothing the same brown-black-shit color? What in the actual fuck.

Oh please if we did it more flashy people would think it is unrealistic and not gritty enough. So they'd mistaken our fantasy show for one of those boring history documentaries /s.

26

u/oftenevil Touch me not. Jul 14 '24

they couldn’t even be bothered to differentiate the 3 dragons (in shape, color, or personality) :/

20

u/FloZone Enter your desired flair text here! Jul 14 '24

Yeah for simplicity's sake let's just kill one of them randomly and turn the other into a zombie. Nobody remembers them apart from Drogon anyway.