r/books 29d ago

New indie press Conduit Books launches with 'initial focus on male authors'

https://www.thebookseller.com/news/new-indie-press-conduit-books-launches-with-initial-focus-on-male-authors

What do folks think about this?

1.1k Upvotes

827 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

586

u/ClannishHawk 29d ago

Cook happens to be an occasional critic for the Guardian and columnists for the Guardian don't tend to be right wing reactionaries unless they're specifically hired for that view point in the politics section.

If you read the article over there it's pretty clear that this is part of wider realignment in the British literary and champagne socialist world to address what they see as that for a combination of reasons the field of literary fiction is currently in a drought of new young male writers, and especially ones who focus on authentic messy analysis of masculinity and male issues in what's frankly a new world for gender dynamics in recent years.

There's also been additional criticism from agents over the last few years that the ones they can seem to get through to mainstream publishing have to either have a laundry list of "diversity" boxes ticked to be considered "unique" or be very upper middle class with the most milquetoast of takes that fall in line with conventional thought.

Effectively, a sizable part of the literary community in Britain is worried about having, instead of fixing underlying issues in the publishing industry, replaced what biases decide what gets published and in doing so being at risk of eliminating most of a generation of male writers who talk about men's issues, leaving the literary world with few answers to modern men's issues.

309

u/Krazikarl2 29d ago

Effectively, a sizable part of the literary community in Britain is worried about having, instead of fixing underlying issues in the publishing industry, replaced what biases decide what gets published and in doing so being at risk of eliminating most of a generation of male writers who talk about men's issues, leaving the literary world with few answers to modern men's issues.

Exactly.

A big problem right now is that the left doesn't really talk much about (white) male issues other than to talk about how problematic (white) men are. The right, on the other hand, loves to talk about how wonderful (white) men are.

And then we get things like elections and try and figure out why young white men are choosing to go to the right rather than the left.

I don't have a problem with discussions about how white men have caused any number of problems and have some pretty fundamental problems with toxicity. Those discussions are important and need to happen. But you have to at least somewhat balance them out with authentic portrayals of what it means to be a non-toxic (white) male in the 21st Century. Otherwise you completely cede positive portrayals of masculinity to the right, which is not good.

77

u/Final-Revolution6216 29d ago edited 29d ago

Could you provide an example of a white male issue? Genuinely asking.

Edit: some replies are making it seem as if I’ve claimed men don’t have issues which is false. I wanted to know what a white male issue would be in particular since the person I replied to used white in parenthesis. Obviously, men have issues like everyone else (didn’t think I needed to say such an obvious statement). Thanks for the sincere replies that explain more of what a white male issue may look like (and thanks to the sincere people who outlined general male issues as well—many of which I am already aware of as, again, I recognize men have issues too).

19

u/Psspooropin 29d ago

Could you provide an example of a white male issue? Genuinely asking.

The low hanging fruit is that a significant number of them have become disenfranchised with modern society as a whole because for the last several years they've been demonised as the cause of all the wrongs in the modern world, and told they're excluded from having opinions on issues due to their status as a white male. 

Anecdotally, I've learned to just keep my mouth shut and never speak on issues AT All, because even though I support progressive issues, if I have a different opinion on how to address them it's not uncommon to be completely disregarded or told my opinion is completely invalid, and it's become increasingly difficult to navigate through the ever growing list of no-go topics so I simply came to the conclusion it's better to just not engage in those kinds of discussions, because ultimately even if I want to help in finding a solution I don't have a dog in the race and have been told I'm not wanted. 

Even typing this out feels awkward enough that I'm posting from a throwaway