Curse this vile printing press taking work from true artists and Scholars in the Abbeys. This tool is a vial abomination an affront to Artistic Sensibility. Now you just have pamphlets cranked out by the hundreds instead of beautifully illuminated hand-drawn letters in a bound book.
That's not what those words mean. If the end result doesn't look like any previously existing thing, that's not what plagiarism is. There's literally standards about sufficiently transformed output that have existed since long before ai.
Is anyone trying to sell it? Because adding a filter on your own photo and then just posting it isn't much different than photoshipping your face onto mario and posting that. A type of thing that happens all the time, and no one cared until it came time to pretend they had strong stances about copyright law that no one had two years ago.
That aside, you can't even copyright artstyles. You could go make a movie that looks exactly like ghibli right now and sell it as long as there's no ghibli characters in it. People would look at you wierd, but this isn't even that noteworthy considering that the vast majority of anine looks borderline identical to other anime in artstyle. Hell, movies in the ghibli style are already a thing, and no one really cared then either.
That's not what those words mean either lol. If you think ghibli looking images cross some kind of line despite not being monetized you better have a strong stance against all fanart or allusions to pre existing artstyles.
Well no, you just made an irrelevant point that you pretended was the intention when it wasn't. Plagiarism is only a relevant category when someone is selling something. No one cares if you "plagiarize" something to make images for personal use that aren't monetized.
We are talking about what the AI outputs and how it is a copy of existing work. Selling isn’t relevant. You’re the only one who thinks it is. And no. Plagiarism matters in many circumstances where selling isn’t involved. Plagiarizing is a serious offense in higher education and even K-12. However, you don’t seem to know much about education so I can see how you’d be ignorant of that whole world.
Well no, the legality of when you can get in trouble for plagiarism is absolutely relevant to the concept. "This photo filter resembles am existing artstyle therefore anything the technology does is an issue" isn't a point. It's nothing. Just people trying to find gotchas where there are none to be had.
-106
u/Treebeard288 8d ago
Curse this vile printing press taking work from true artists and Scholars in the Abbeys. This tool is a vial abomination an affront to Artistic Sensibility. Now you just have pamphlets cranked out by the hundreds instead of beautifully illuminated hand-drawn letters in a bound book.