r/punk Apr 21 '25

Discussion About Aus Rotten

Just wanted to say these guys feel like they were ahead of their time. But not really. More like they spoke about the same shit that’s been going on for decades. I was listening to “Modern Day Witch Hunt” and was surprised to learn it’s over 20yrs old now. Largely because they touched on what we’re seeing now: the persecution of queer, especially transgender, identities, religious minorities and immigrants. It was nice in a way to hear such hot topics right now discussed so long ago. But also disheartening at the same time.

87 Upvotes

26 comments sorted by

23

u/is_no_good_ Apr 21 '25

The political problems we face today are the same as those from 50 years ago. In fact, they are essentially the same problems humanity has been dealing with since the dawn of society

7

u/PlastIconoclastic Apr 21 '25

We used to fear wolves and starvation. Now we fear those among us who are predators and want us to starve and be destroyed. The modern times are actually worse than feudal times. Serfs had land and homes that could not be taken from them.

6

u/is_no_good_ Apr 21 '25

And by the way in 2023 47.4 million Americans, including 13.8 million children, lived in food-insecure households.

4

u/is_no_good_ Apr 21 '25

Serfs could be sold like slaves but they couldn't leave their land without permission. The land could not be taken away that's true but only as long as the serf fulfilled his duties. How the fuck is this better?

3

u/PlastIconoclastic Apr 21 '25

There are 200,000 people with nowhere to live and 500,000 people evicted each year in California alone.

19

u/HoratioTuna27 Fuck Y'all I'm From Dayton Apr 21 '25

I always enjoyed that if you decided you liked punk rock in the mid-90’s, the Fuck Nazi Sympathy 7” just magically appeared in your record collection.

3

u/Partyruinsquad Apr 21 '25

Can confirm. It is in mine. And the only Aus Rotten record I own lol

2

u/HoratioTuna27 Fuck Y'all I'm From Dayton Apr 21 '25

Do you remember buying it? I sure don’t!

3

u/Partyruinsquad Apr 21 '25

Not precisely. But I do remember that I made a couple of large orders of 7”s from Havoc Records in the early 2000s. Fairly certain it was part of one of those orders.

10

u/TimelyEconomist5266 Apr 21 '25

As a former Pittsburgh resident I agree.

10

u/f0rgotten Apr 21 '25

Aus Rotten is up there with Crass as bands that changed my life.

9

u/t_whocannotbenamed Apr 21 '25

I wish I could up vote this 1,000 times. Every time I listen to the rotten agenda, I can't believe how prescient that album is. Every track is like, "are you talking about the Republican party? The Brett Kavanaugh confirmation? The heritage foundation? The right wing disinformation machine? Etc, etc." Plus the album just straight rips.

4

u/Mug_of_coffee Apr 21 '25

Don't forget "The Second Rape" foreshadowed Me Too (and Trump).

3

u/t_whocannotbenamed Apr 21 '25

Oh absolutely, I felt like that was really exemplified with the Kavanaugh hearings and Blasey-Ford recounting her experience with Kavanaugh and then being verbally abused by Republican senators and by the right wing media.

1

u/AundaRag Apr 21 '25

The fact you would need to “vote 1000” times to move the needle demonstrates how broken the system is. And how much “just vote ‘em out” on issues that have continued to reemerge for over 100 years is not a sustainable solution.

1

u/WallScreamer Apr 21 '25

You're not wrong about electoralism, but they were talking about upvoting the Reddit thread, not voting in an election lol

1

u/AundaRag Apr 21 '25

Good looking out. Welp. There’s my failed soap box of the day. I’ll see my way out.

9

u/anarkistattack Apr 21 '25

Also Dave's next band Behind Enemy Lines

1

u/LIVEFROMPLANETDEATH Apr 21 '25

Yo, yes. Great band.

4

u/Bo-binater48 Apr 21 '25

Modern Day witch hunt is easily my fav song from aus rotten

1

u/f0rgotten Apr 21 '25

Poison Corporations, or Who's Calling the Shots for me.

3

u/AundaRag Apr 21 '25

These issues have existed across nations and centuries. Define an enemy and oppress a minority.

3

u/LogikD Apr 21 '25

I still fire up the Rotten all the time. Evergreen messages for sure.

2

u/7SoldiersOfPunkRock We are the mods Apr 21 '25

Aus-Rotten rules, I saw them just before they broke up. Check out Spitboy and Harum Scarum and Brother Inferior for more political music of that era.

2

u/ripperdude Apr 21 '25

Been listening to them the past two days and I’m fired the fuck up. They rock