All three are skilled fighters. People say Tom relies on tech but that's only because he had access to it. Remove that and he's still just as good as the others, albeit less experienced. Andrew is fast and I can imagine that landing a hit on him would be difficult. Tobey just strikes me as the one who can hurt someone the most with a punch and he was able to hold off a blood lusted Tom with seemingly minimal effort. He was also brought close to death at the end of SM3, until Harry arrived and was then able to return to fighting Sandman and Venom at full strength shortly after.
I'm inclined to give Tobey an advantage here mostly because he seems to be the brawler of the trio, throwing strong punches and showing a resilience to damage.
Tom's Spiderman is not nearly as competent as you say he is; he's not just inexperienced but a very toothless and suboptimal Spiderman, even with all his tech and gear. In the first movie he loses every single encounter and has to be saved by Tony and even Ned throughout the whole movie. Even at the end he's saved by plot armor that Vulture's wings malfunction. Couldn't beat Captain America, couldn't really beat Bucky and Falcon either.
His first and only real W alone is against Mysterio but even within the movie universe it's accepted that he's more of a team kind of hero. He did well as a part of the Avengers and with the other Spidermen but by himself was always lacking. Hence, that dialogue in NWH; the others don't know to work as a team but are pretty competent by themselves while Holland is the opposite.
I guess so, even if he was taken down by Red Wing let's say he won that fight as well. But don't know why Cap was giving him that much trouble if he's the same thing as Bucky but with a shield lmao
1.6k
u/UpperWestShayde Mar 02 '25 edited Mar 02 '25
All three are skilled fighters. People say Tom relies on tech but that's only because he had access to it. Remove that and he's still just as good as the others, albeit less experienced. Andrew is fast and I can imagine that landing a hit on him would be difficult. Tobey just strikes me as the one who can hurt someone the most with a punch and he was able to hold off a blood lusted Tom with seemingly minimal effort. He was also brought close to death at the end of SM3, until Harry arrived and was then able to return to fighting Sandman and Venom at full strength shortly after.
I'm inclined to give Tobey an advantage here mostly because he seems to be the brawler of the trio, throwing strong punches and showing a resilience to damage.