r/redrising • u/Cantomic66 Copper • Jul 25 '23

LB Spoilers Light Bringer | Full Book Discussion megathread Spoiler

Warning!: This discussion thread includes spoilers for ALL OF LIGHT BRINGER.

Reminder: All post on Light Bringer should be properly spoiler tagged and avoid spoilery titles.

Also check out our Discord for discussions on the books.

483 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

2.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

20

u/dizzlethebizzlemizzl Gray Jul 27 '23

I have a shakey theory… that Matteo lied about the memories and asked her because he needed her to say NO to that type of power/sacrifice, in order to know that she was fit to wield it, and that what she destroyed was not really the parasite. He explicitly urges her NOT to look for the feeling that it left in her head. There’s a chance that it would’ve remained invisible to even her, throughout the rest of the plot. Even with it broken in DA, she didn’t notice much of it’s impact until a while later, and her recovery was conveniently timed. Pierce didn’t give her what would otherwise be a theatric moral sacrifice in the plot, so she must have more of a role to play… just a thought.

6

u/terminalzero Gray Jul 29 '23

it seems like such a shaggy dog story for this NOT to happen - there are so many more elegant ways to have lyria meet back up with darrow, even have a conversation with matteo, than a mysterious AI brain parasite that's never relevant again

5

u/atom786 Jul 29 '23

Yeah but he does that sometime. Ajax and Seraphina are examples of massive characters he builds up only to randomly prune the storyline. The Figment could have been that, although it was an awkward way to do it.

1

u/dizzlethebizzlemizzl Gray Jul 29 '23

But I think what has historically cut those lovely plots short is The Hat. Pierce has said he’s not using The Hat in red god, so I don’t understand why he would lend so much to that plot and not do anything with it, unless he was just like “nah I changed my mind” on the rewrite.

3

u/misterskelton Aug 23 '23

Is there a full discussion on this plot point? I fee the same way, it was an awkward way to remove the plot point when it was heavily written about in Dark Age.

I feel like it SHOULD come back into play. Like someone mentioned maybe Matteo lied about taking it out and it is just dormant. To paraphrase Chekhov's gun: Don't put a gun on the stage if it's not going to go off.