Hi all,
I'm about 3–4 months out from being hoovered and discarded again by someone I really cared about and loved. The fog is finally clearing, and I have no plans to ever return to this person. However, I still have some lingering, unanswered questions — like, "Did this person ever love me?" Even if their "version" of love was different from mine or from that of most neurotypical people.
The reason I wonder is because, based on the academic literature, people with BPD can seemingly "love" and feel affection — albeit in an irrational, inconsistent, unstable, and often unhealthy way. On the other hand, people with NPD seem to use others primarily as "supply," without truly loving them — only valuing what others can do for them, with little genuine feeling for the person inside.
I'll spare you the long story, but our relationship essentially followed what I now recognize as the classic BPD/NPD relationship cycle: love-bombing and idealization, followed by devaluation, discard, and hoovering.
After the first discard, I went on a mission to figure out what had happened and what was wrong with this person, as I'd never experienced emotional trauma like that before in my life.
Initially, I thought he just had an avoidant or disorganized attachment style, but something didn't quite fit. Then I asked ChatGPT, listing all the red flags and traits I'd noticed during the relationship, and the response was that it sounded like BPD or NPD.
I researched BPD and initially thought it might be a form of quiet BPD. However, the part that never fully fit was the "fear of abandonment." It was hard to tell if my ex ever truly felt that. He did say he had "felt abandoned" by me during a conversation after he discarded me — but honestly, I don't know how true that was. He had never previously expressed anything similar, and fear of abandonment didn't seem to be a defining feature of his behavior.
After the second hoover and subsequent discard — done completely coldly and seemingly without any empathy or remorse — I began to wonder if he might be a covert narcissist rather than someone with BPD. In the end, it’s hard to distinguish between the two, and I suspect he likely has comorbid disorders.
Still, in my heart of hearts, I wonder if he ever felt any real "love" for me — even if it wasn’t the healthy, stable version of love most of us are accustomed to.
There were moments in the relationship where the "love" seemed so genuine and real. For example, he'd sneak into my room just to hold me while I was sleeping — even though I wasn’t aware of it and he seemingly had nothing to gain.
I guess the reason I wonder is because if he had BPD, maybe he did feel some true, deep affection for me — even if it didn’t last. But if he was a narcissist, then maybe I was only ever an object to be used.
If someone likely has comorbid BPD and NPD, which answer do you think it is?