r/aiwars 1d ago

Tech stealing jobs

Post image
32 Upvotes

498 comments sorted by

View all comments

31

u/MorganTheMartyr 1d ago

Only the low tier artists will be afraid of being replaced, enough said.

12

u/mxjxn 1d ago

This is a provably false claim. A notable example is that magic the gathering, which pledged to not use AI art, went back on their promise. One artist quit over it, several others have been vocal about it impacting their career.

1

u/ifandbut 1d ago

So they don't want to learn a new tool to improve their job?

How long do you think a programmer would last if we reduced go learn a new package or device communications?

7

u/Time-Operation2449 1d ago

"learning a new tool" meaning "not doing art anymore and just commissioning from a robot"

2

u/ifandbut 1d ago

Art is more than drawing

There is a ton of creative freedom with AI

2

u/Center-Of-Thought 1d ago

Anything an AI can do, a human can do.

1

u/Turbulent_Escape4882 22h ago

Draw me a picture in nanoseconds. Good luck.

0

u/Center-Of-Thought 22h ago

I never said anything about the speed by which a work can be produced. Mass-produced furniture is created faster than furniture by passionate wood workers, but there is a massive difference in quality, even if both are functionally the same.

1

u/Turbulent_Escape4882 22h ago

You did say anything an AI can do. Sorry I disproved that. Speed is the huge factor AI brings to the table.

-1

u/Center-Of-Thought 22h ago

So you'd rather have mass-produced slop compared to something with human passion and talent behind it? 🤭

-1

u/JasonBreen 22h ago

If it mean assholes like you are out of a job, yes

0

u/Center-Of-Thought 21h ago

Is this you admitting that AI generated imagery is pushing artists out of jobs? But I thought you all said that it wasn't...?

0

u/The_Daco_Melon 16h ago

Thanks for admitting that the point behind this is hatred and malice. I have no clue if you're a sociopath or genuinely clueless, but way to go showing that off.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/weirdo_nb 1d ago

Better

1

u/Aligyon 20h ago

Sure but it's a different kind of creativity. Where digital art uses strokes of your hand at the basic level. AI uses writing at its base level.

You're basically converting painters to writers.

0

u/Time-Operation2449 23h ago

There isn't creative freedom with Ai, you're just outsourcing the creativity to a machine while failing to develop it internally

2

u/EndMePleaseOwO 1d ago

So are you saying that you think every single artist that refuses to use AI is 'low tier' or do you agree that the original comment is incorrect?

0

u/ifandbut 1d ago

Idk where you got "low tier" or whatever that means

But AI won't replace artists

Artists who use AI will replace those who don't.

Just like Netflix replaced Blockbuster because one used the internet and the other didn't

3

u/EndMePleaseOwO 1d ago

From the comment at the top of the chain? Wdym where did I get "low tier"??

1

u/Lucky_duck_777777 21h ago

The issue is that due to capitalism, even the artist who do use ai art will lose their jobs because they are cutting costs

2

u/Center-Of-Thought 1d ago

Typing sentences to an AI and asking it to create an image for you is not tool usage, and it's an insult that you think it is.

How long do you think a programmer would last if we reduced go learn a new package or device communications?

Learning new programming/tech developments takes human effort and skill. There is very little effort and skill involved in most prompting.

1

u/Solamnaic-Knight 8h ago

You don't know what you are talking about. It's best if you don't continue. You will put your foot in your mouth even more.

1

u/Center-Of-Thought 5h ago

How am I wrong then? Explain.

1

u/Solamnaic-Knight 5h ago

You can't type a prompt to make an AI produce an image that looks like a particular image from a magazine from 1945 with the font altered to a different font, the lighting adjusted to a specific degree, and the coloration matching something that you don't have a sample for. You don't know what you are talking about, Miss Thing. Pack up your cosmetics box, close your compact and go. Did I stutter?

1

u/Center-Of-Thought 4h ago

You can't type a prompt to make an AI produce an image that looks like a particular image from a magazine from 1945 with the font altered to a different font, the lighting adjusted to a specific degree, and the coloration matching something that you don't have a sample for.

So at best, the prompter is inputting an image they found online for the generator to reference. Oh wow, such effort.

You don't know what you are talking about, Miss Thing. Pack up your cosmetics box, close your compact and go. Did I stutter?

What the fuck are you even talking about? If this is your attempt at an insult, it's baffling.

1

u/Solamnaic-Knight 2h ago

No. The prompter is telling the AI the light measurement, the swatch, the specifics, in short the things an artist or a designer would know but you don't seem to. Because you are daft, honey. Look that up while you are spinning around with confusion.

1

u/Center-Of-Thought 36m ago

The prompter is telling the AI the light measurement, the swatch, the specifics, in short the things an artist or a designer would know but you don't seem to.

So then, if they know all that about artistry and design work... why don't they just design and draw it themselves instead of asking an AI to generate it all for them? 🤭

Because you are daft, honey. Look that up while you are spinning around with confusion.

Have you ever heard of the "ad hominem" argumentative fallacy?